Abstract:Probabilities of Causation (PoC) play a fundamental role in decision-making in law, health care and public policy. Nevertheless, their point identification is challenging, requiring strong assumptions, in the absence of which only bounds can be derived. Existing work to further tighten these bounds by leveraging extra information either provides numerical bounds, symbolic bounds for fixed dimensionality, or requires access to multiple datasets that contain the same treatment and outcome variables. However, in many clinical, epidemiological and public policy applications, there exist external datasets that examine the effect of different treatments on the same outcome variable, or study the association between covariates and the outcome variable. These external datasets cannot be used in conjunction with the aforementioned bounds, since the former may entail different treatment assignment mechanisms, or even obey different causal structures. Here, we provide symbolic bounds on the PoC for this challenging scenario. We focus on combining either two randomized experiments studying different treatments, or a randomized experiment and an observational study, assuming causal sufficiency. Our symbolic bounds work for arbitrary dimensionality of covariates and treatment, and we discuss the conditions under which these bounds are tighter than existing bounds in literature. Finally, our bounds parameterize the difference in treatment assignment mechanism across datasets, allowing the mechanisms to vary across datasets while still allowing causal information to be transferred from the external dataset to the target dataset.

Sharp Bounds on Causal Effects in Case-Control and Cohort Studies

Causal bounds for outcome-dependent sampling in observational studies

Nonparametric bounds for causal effects in imperfect randomized experiments

Doubly-Valid/Doubly-Sharp Sensitivity Analysis for Causal Inference with Unmeasured Confounding

Bounds on Causal Effects and Application to High Dimensional Data

Treatment Effects on Ordinal Outcomes: Causal Estimands and Sharp Bounds

A unified framework for bounding causal effects on the always-survivor and other populations

Scalable Computation of Causal Bounds

Approximate Causal Effect Identification under Weak Confounding

Causal inference with a quantitative exposure

Towards Bounding Causal Effects under Markov Equivalence

Bounds on Direct and Indirect Effects of Treatment on a Continuous Endpoint.

Bounds and Sensitivity Analysis of the Causal Effect Under Outcome-Independent MNAR Confounding

SHARP BOUNDS FOR VARIANCE OF TREATMENT EFFECT ESTIMATORS IN THE PRESENCE OF COVARIATES

Causal Inference with High-dimensional Discrete Covariates

Causal Bounds and Instruments

Relaxed covariate overlap and margin-based causal effect estimation

A sensitivity analysis approach for the causal hazard ratio in randomized and observational studies

Causal inference for semi-competing risks data

Tightening Bounds on Probabilities of Causation By Merging Datasets

Probably approximately correct high-dimensional causal effect estimation given a valid adjustment set