Abstract:This paper addresses the problem of estimating causal effects when adjustment variables in the back-door or front-door criterion are partially observed. For such scenarios, we derive bounds on the causal effects by solving two non-linear optimization problems, and demonstrate that the bounds are sufficient. Using this optimization method, we propose a framework for dimensionality reduction that allows one to trade bias for estimation power, and demonstrate its performance using simulation studies.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve the problem of how to estimate causal effects in causal inference when the adjustment variables in the back - door or front - door criteria are partially observable or of high dimension. Specifically, the paper proposes to obtain the bounds of causal effects by solving two nonlinear optimization problems and proves that these bounds are sufficient. In addition, the paper also proposes a new framework for dealing with the case of high - dimensional adjustment variables. This framework allows researchers to make trade - offs between bias and estimation ability, and its performance is demonstrated through simulation studies.
### Background and Problem Description of the Paper
Estimating causal effects is a key issue in many industries, marketing, and health sciences. The back - door and front - door criteria and their adjustment formulas proposed by Pearl are powerful tools for estimating causal effects. However, when the adjustment variables in these criteria are partially observable or of high dimension, traditional methods for estimating causal effects face challenges. For example, if some confounders are partially unobserved, or the number of adjustment variables is very large, traditional estimation methods may not be able to provide accurate estimates of causal effects.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
1. **Bounds of Causal Effects for Partially Observable Adjustment Variables**:
- When the adjustment variables in the back - door or front - door criteria are partially observable, the paper solves the lower and upper bounds of causal effects by introducing the prior distribution \( P(U) \) and the observed covariates \( W \) and using a nonlinear optimization method.
- Specifically, for the partially observable back - door variables, the paper proposes the following optimization problems:
\[
\text{LB} = \min \sum_{w, u} \frac{a_{w, u} b_{w, u}}{c_{w, u}}
\]
\[
\text{UB} = \max \sum_{w, u} \frac{a_{w, u} b_{w, u}}{c_{w, u}}
\]
where \( \sum_{u} a_{w, u} = P(x, y, w) \), \( \sum_{u} b_{w, u} = P(w) \), \( \sum_{u} c_{w, u} = P(x, w) \), and a series of constraint conditions are satisfied.
- For the partially observable front - door variables, optimization problems are proposed similarly.
2. **Dimension Reduction Framework for High - Dimensional Adjustment Variables**:
- When the adjustment variables are of high dimension, directly estimating causal effects requires a very large sample size, which is usually unrealistic in practical applications.
- The paper proposes a new framework that transforms the problem of high - dimensional adjustment variables into an equivalent low - dimensional problem. The specific method is to introduce two new nodes \( W \) and \( U \) and map the high - dimensional variable \( Z \) in the original problem to these two new nodes.
- Through this method, the bounds of causal effects can be estimated with a smaller sample size, and the midpoint of the bounds can be taken as the estimate of the causal effect.
### Experimental Verification
The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed bound - estimation method through a simulation experiment of drug efficacy. The experimental results show that the midpoint of the causal - effect bounds obtained using the optimization method proposed in the paper can be very close to the actual causal effect, especially when the causal effect is close to 0 or 1.
### Conclusion
The paper successfully solves the problem of estimating causal effects in the cases of partially observable adjustment variables and high - dimensional adjustment variables. Through nonlinear optimization methods and dimension - reduction frameworks, practical solutions are provided. These methods are not only of great theoretical significance but also show good performance in practical applications.