Abstract:This working paper was written by Jiandong Ju (Shanghai University of Finance and Economics, Tsinghua University and Hong Kong Institute for Monetary Research), Ziru Wei (Tsinghua University) and Hong Ma (Tsinghua University).From 1992 to 2011, the total trade volume between the U.S. and China increased by 25 times, and China's share in U.S. total imports increased from 5% to 20%. However, the U.S.'s share in China's total imports dropped from 11% to 8% in the same period. In the major categories of U.S. exports to China, waste & scrap increased from 744 million dollars in 2000 to 7,562 million dollars in 2008, rising 916% times and becoming the no.1 product that the U.S exports to China. It is important to understand what explains these structural changes, and to ask whether the principle of comparative advantage determines the structure of U.S.-China bilateral trade. Interestingly, we find an "Anti-Comparative Advantage" puzzle: the U.S. exports less to China in sectors where it has greater comparative advantage, while China exports more to the U.S. in its sectors with greater comparative advantage. To further study this issue, we extend Eaton-Kortum model of bilateral trade to multiple sectors and test it empirically using US and China trade data. We find that after controlling for the importer's demand, trade costs and factor intensities, etc., comparative advantage cannot explain U.S.-China bilateral trade flows. The puzzle survives various robustness checks.

Trade Statistical Discrepancies and U.S.-China Trade Balance Issues

On the Issues Between FDI in China and Sino-U. S. Trade Balance

U.S.-China Trade Deficit: An Empirical Research

U.S. Export Controls and the Issue of the Sino-U.S. Trade Balance

The U.S.-China Trade Balance and RMB's Exchange Rate: an Empirical Analysis

An Analysis of Core Factors Contributing U.S – China Trade Imbalance

Revealed Comparative Advantage, Intra Industry Trade and the Us Manufacturing Trade Deficit with China

Does the China-U.S. Trade Imbalance Stem from Difference in the Comparative Advantages of Service Trade? Empirical Analysis Based on SVAR Model

An Analysis of Core Factors Contributing to U.S. - China Trade Imbalance

Understanding the Global Imbalance from the Perspective of Processing Trade Value Added of China

Empirical Study on the Impact of US FDI on China-US Bilateral Trade Imbalances

Explicit Comparative Advantages,Intra-industry Trade,and Sino-US Bilateral Trade Balance

An Analysis on Underlying Causes of Sino-US Trade Surplus

On Sino-US Economic factors, Real Exchange Rate and Sino-US Trade Balance

What determines China's trade balance dynamics: a disaggregate analysis of panel data

Economic Benefits and Pollutants Emission Embodied in China–US Merchandise Trade—Comparative Analysis Based on Gross Trade, Value Added Trade and Value Added in Trade

Understanding the recent Sino-U.S. trade conflict

Antidumping and U.S.-China Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade:An Empirical Analysis

Trade in Factor Income and the US-China Trade Balance

The Impact of FDI on China's Current Account in the Balance of Payments:An Empirical Analysis from 1982 to 2006

Anti-Comparative Advantage: A Puzzle in U.S.-China Bilateral Trade