Abstract:Background: Understanding and solving problems involves different levels of representation. On the one hand, there are logico-mathematical representations, or problem models (PMs), which contain information such as 'the size of the flock changed from 31 sheep to 42' while, on the other hand, there are more qualitative representations, or qualitative situation models (QSMs), comprising events expressed in everyday terms, such as 'a lot of lambs had been born'. Aims: We set out to show that an apparent contradiction between a PM and a QSM can result in poorer performances, especially when the activation of formal representations is not fully automatic. Sample: We tested 44 third years (mean age 8;6) and 46 fourth years (mean age 9; 8) from two primary schools in France. Method: Change problems and compare problems were drafted in two versions: one where the QSM and PM were consistent and one where they appeared to be contradictory but were not (referred to hereafter as the inconsistent version). For example, if the numerical data proved that the size of a flock of sheep had increased (PM), the consistent version would state that a lot of lambs had been born (QSM), whereas the inconsistent version would state that the wolf had devoured some of the sheep (QSM). Each pupil was given 7 consistent problems and 7 'inconsistent' ones to solve. Results: For the change problems, errors were more frequent on the inconsistent versions, especially among the younger subjects. For the compare problems, there were more errors on the inconsistent versions regardless of the subjects' age. Conclusion: It is in situations where the problem schema is not automatically activated (younger subjects or compare problems) that the QSM plays its role of intermediate representation and causes performances to deteriorate if it does not correspond to the PM.

Difference on Representation Strategy in Arithmetic Word Problems of Mathematical Superior and Inferior Students in Elementary Second Grade

A Study of Difference of Elementary Second to Fourth Graders' Representation Strategy in Arithmetic Word Problem

Whether Verbal and Visuospatial Working Memory Play Different Roles in Pupil’s Mathematical Abilities

On the Different Types of Representations of Elementary Students' Arithmatic Word Problems and Their Effects Upon Word Problem Solving

The Feature Of Elementary Fourth To Sixth Graders' Representational Level In Math Word Problem And Its Influence On Problem-Solving

The Influence of Math Ability and Question Position on Primary Students＇ Representations of Ill-structured Word Problems

Measuring Students' Representation Level on Arithmetic Word Problems: Based on the Relational-Representational Complexity Model

A comparison of strategic development for multiplication problem solving in low-, average-, and high-achieving students

A Study on Difference in Mathematical Problem Representation among Students of Different Grades

Mathematics-Difficulty Children's Representations and Its Effects on the Word-Problem Solving

Elementary Students' Representational Model in Math Word Problem and Relationship with Representational Level

The Performance of Chinese Primary School Students on Realistic Arithmetic Word Problems

Arithmetic problems at school: when there is an apparent contradiction between the situation model and the problem model

Effects of Fitting / Ill-fitted representations on Word Problem Solving

The Study of the Representation of Thinking in Problem-Finding Process of the Undergraduates

A Study on the Difference Between the Mongol and Han Pupils in Solving the Realistic Practical Mathematics Problem

Examining the Differences of the 8Th-Graders' Estimation Performance Between Contextual and Numerical Problems

A investigation on Mathematical Representational Competency for Grade 8 Students in China

Research on the Representation of Different Sort of Problem-solving of Children with Mathematics Learning Disability

An Analysis of the Representation of Problem Types in Chinese and US Mathematics Textbooks

Arithmetic word problem solving. Analysis of Singaporean and Spanish textbooks