Examining the Differences of the 8Th-Graders' Estimation Performance Between Contextual and Numerical Problems

Der-Ching,Jinfu Yang,Shin-Shin,Kan Wu

2012-01-01

Abstract:Two 12-question estimation instruments were designed to compare the differences of estimating strategies used by the 8th-graders when solving contextual and numerical problems. Both instruments are parallel, meaning that the numbers used in both instruments are the same; however, they were presented differently. One hundred and ninety-eight 8th-graders in southern Taiwan were selected to participate in this study. The correct percentage for the numerical problems and contextual problems were 45% and 33%, respectively. The t-test result shows a significant difference for the estimation performance between contextual and numerical problems at α = 0.05. This implies that these 8th-graders perform significantly better on numerical problems than that of contextual problems. In addition, the t-test results show that there is a significant difference in the performance of reformulation, transformation, and compensation dimensions for numerical and contextual problems at α = 0.05, respectively. The results show that students performed better on numerical problems than on contextual problems for each dimension. In addition, data show that students tended to use the written method to solve numerical and contextual problems instead of estimation. Implications are discussed.