An Analysis of the Representation of Problem Types in Chinese and US Mathematics Textbooks

Zhu Yan,Fan Lianghuo

2004-01-01

Abstract:This study compared how Chinese and US school mathematics textbooks at the lower secondary level represent various types of problems. The study formulated seven main classifications of problem types, including routine problems versus non-routine problems, open-ended problems versus close-ended problems, traditional problems versus non-traditional problems, application problems versus non-application problems, among others. Both similarities and differences on the representation of problems in the textbooks between the two countries were investigated. In general, the majority of problems in all the examined textbooks were routine, traditional, and close-ended. Most problems in both countries' books were not contextualized in real world situations. More types of non-traditional problems were found in the US textbooks and the distribution of the non-traditional problems in the US books was also more balanced. However, problems in the US textbooks were overall less challenging than those in the Chinese books, in terms of the number of steps involved in the problem solutions. The possible reasons (including from both social and cultural perspectives) for the similarities and especially for the differences were explored in the study. Moreover, the results from the textbook comparisons were used to analyze possible influences of those textbooks on students' different performance in mathematics as revealed in cross-national comparisons. Suggestions about how to improve the representation of problems in mathematics textbooks were provided at the end of the study.