Comparative Analysis of Three Treatments of Upper Urinary Calculi with Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy
Jiajun YAN,Guanfu ZHANG,Shouhua PAN,Jiangang PAN,Guiliang TANG,Aijuan TANG,Gang XU,Gangfeng WU,Junlong LI,Guoqiang XU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-1420.2010.04.009
2010-01-01
Journal of Clinical Urology
Abstract:Objective:To compare the efficacy and safety of Lee s nephroscope. standard Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) and minimally invasive PCNL, and improve the level of treatment in Upper urinary calculi. Methods:From January 2005 to January 2009,three treatments of upper urinary calculi with PCNL were performed in 132 patients,include 87 cases of kidney calculi (There were 56 renal units with singer or multi- kidney pelvic and calyceal calculi,31 renal units with staghorn calculi) and 45 renal units with upper ureteral calculi. Standard percutaneous nephrolithotomy lithotomy 34 cases, the mean age was 57 years (range 34-78 years); the average stone diameter was 3. 5 em(range 2. 3-5. 8 cm) . renal units with staghorn calculi 14 case. Minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy PCNL in 52 cases,the mean age was51(range 31-77 years), the average stone diameter was 3. 3 cm(range 2. 1-5. 0 cm) , renal units with staghorn calculi 8 case. Lee s nephroscope , standard PCNL and minimally invasive PCNL were performed in 46,the mean age was 55 years(range 29-81 years) ,the average stone diameter was 3. 0 cm(range 2. 0-5. 5 cm) , and there were 9 staghorn calculi patients . Clinical date including the time of operation and nephrostomy tube for drainage, phase 1 stone-free rate and blood loss volume of operation were compared. Results:The operative time for upper ureteral calculi was(56±5)min, phase 1 stone-free rate for Upper urinary calculi was 80. 43%, blood loss volume of operation was( 156±38)ml and the rate of tansfusion was 2. 17% in Lee's nephroscope for Upper urinary calculi with PCNL. which had significant difference with another two treatments of upper urinary calculi with PCNL. 6 patients of renal units with singer kidney pelvic calculi had no blooding, urinary leakage and fever or infection following Tubeless Lee s nephroscope in PCNL. Conclusions: Lee's nephroscope in PCNL can improve the efficiency, accelerate the speed, reduce the residual stones and the complications of operation.