Comparison of Retrograde Flexible Ureteroscopic Lithotripsy and Mini-Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy for Calyceal Calculi
GAO Xiao-feng,ZHOU Tie,CHEN Shu-shang,GAO Xu,WANG Lin-hui,XU Chuan-liang,SUN Ying-hao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-3253.2007.02.002
2007-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the therapeutic effect of retrograde flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy and mini-percutaneous nephrolithotomy (MPCNL) for calyceal calculi.Methods We retrospectively analyzed the data of 138 patients treated in our urologic center for calyceal calculi.Of them,55 patients underwent retrograde flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy while 83 patients were performed by MPCNL.The success rate of stone fragmentation,the mean operating time and hospitalization days of patients undergoing flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy or MPCNL were recorded. Results For patients with superior calyceal calculi≥2 cm,the operating time of flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy and MPCNL was (56±7.0) min and (52±9.2) min,fragmentation rate was 66.7% and 87.5%.For patients with superior calyceal calculi<2 cm,the operating time of 2 groups was (42±9.0) min and (44±9.9) min respectively,fragmentation rate was 91.7% and 100%.For patients with medium calyceal calculi≥2 cm,the operating time of 2 groups was (59±7.9) min and (48±10.3) min,fragmentation rate was 66.7% and 95.2% respectively.For patients with medium calyceal calculi<2 cm,the operating time of 2 groups was (38±8.4) min and (43±10.5) min respectively,fragmentation rate was 100% and 100%.For patients with inferior calyceal calculi≥2 cm, the operating time of 2 groups was (68±9.3) min and (44±10.2) min,fragmentation rate was 51.7% and 92.6% respectively.For patients with inferior calyceal calculi<2 cm,the operating time of 2 groups was (56±5.3)min and (40±10.1)min respectively,fragmentation rate was 66.7% and 100%.No severe complications occurred in 2 groups.Longer hospitalization was needed for patients undergoing MPCNL than those flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy.Conclusions The calyceal calculi≥2 cm in diameter should be recommended for MPCNL,regardless of it's location.For superior or medium calyceal calculi<2 cm in diameter,retrograde flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy is firstly recommended; while for inferior calyceal calculi<2 cm in diameter,MPCNL is the optimal treatment.