Action Filed by a Third Person on the Subject Matter of Enforcement
Zhang Weiping
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-6676.2009.04.039
2009-01-01
Abstract:§ 204 of the new Civil Procedure Law of China stipulates that, "If, during the course of enforcement, a person who is not involved in the case raises a written objection to the subject matter of the enforcement, the people's court shall review the written objection within 15 days after receiving it. If the objection is tenable, the people's court shall rule to suspend the enforcement on the subject matter; and if the objection is untenable, it shall be rejected. If a person who is not involved in the case or a party involved is not satisfied with the ruling and considers that there is an error in the original judgment or ruling, it shall be dealt with according to the procedure of adjudication supervision; and if a written objection is irrelevant to the original judgment or ruling, the relevant party may file a lawsuit with the people's court within 15 days after the ruling is served. " That is to say, if the error concerning the subject matter of enforcement is not attribu- ted to the original judgment or ruling, a person who is not involved in the case can achieve the relief for his substantive rights by way of filing a lawsuit. However, there exist still some questions about the so said lawsuit, such as its function and nature, its plaintiff and defendant, its area of application, etc. , which should be clarified. According to the tradition of civil law system, there are principally three types of lawsuits,that is, the lawsuit for performance, for confirmation and for alternation. But the so said lawsuit belongs to none of them. It is a special type of lawsuit, having dual functions and purposes, that is, to confirm the substantive right of the plaintiff on the subject matter of enforcement, and meanwhile to order the enforcement organ to terminate or withdraw the enforcement on the subject matter. To the contrary, in a pure confirmation or alternation suit, such dual purposes cannot be satisfied. The plaintiff of the so said lawsuit is the person who is not involved in the original case but argues substantive right on the subject matter of enforcement. Usually, the defendant of the so said lawsuit is the applicant of enforcement, only in special circumstance can the obligor of the original case also be the defendant. The so said lawsuit can be applied as long as the subject matter of enforcement is about property.