Intellectual or Expert:Behind the Dualism in Communication Studies
Hu Yiqing
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13495/j.cnki.cjjc.2010.04.007
2010-01-01
Journal of International Communication
Abstract:The duality between critical school and positivism school has been a common sense for communications researchers, whose origin is universally considered the duality between Columbia School and Frankfurt School;however, contrary to what most people think,between the two schools there has been no ingrained contradictions,but profound friendship which once made nearly possible the integration of them structurally.If anything,that should be the contradiction in value orientations of their studies.Columbia School was prone to be the organization of experts of political power or business power,while Frankfurt School,critical intellectuals.Actually,the duality between them was the fruit of the academic history researchers in the 1970s who wrote the history.The reason why these researchers recognized the phenomenon is not only the clearer distinction between their study orientations after the institutionalization movement in America's social sciences community,but also the crisis of lacking creativity in communication studies featuring their expert style.Nevertheless,Frankfurt School is doomed to be incapable of fundamentally ameliorating the communication studies,due to the incompatibility between intellectual mode and expert mode.