Comparative analysis of some representative models of viscosity versus pressure in the case of various hydrocarbons and their mixtures
C. Boned,A. Et-Tahir,B. Lagourette,P. Xans,Guanghua Gao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02663734
IF: 2.013
1996-01-01
Journal of Thermal Science
Abstract:A critical study of some representative models has been conducted with the experimental determinations of the viscosity of
ten pure substances and three binary systems measured as a function of temperatureT (25�C, 40�C, 60�C, 80�C, 90�C) and pressureP(≤ 100 MPa). The pure substances were: toluene, p-xylene, m-xylene, o-xylene, methylcyclohexane, methylnaphtalene, decahydronaphtalene,
phenyldodecane, heptamethylnonane and tetramethylpentadecane (pristane). The three binaries were: toluene + tetramethylpentadecane,
toluene + methylnaphtalene and toluene + heptamethylnonane, for molar fractions x of toluene ranging between 0 and 1. The
three binaries are highly “contrasted” systems, i.e. systems in which the viscosities of the pure components are very different
for eachP, T pair. In all, 547 experimental determinations were carried out, the 279 experimental data for viscosity of the pure substances
and 268 data concerning the mixtures (x ≠ 0 and 1) were used to make a critical analysis of the various representative models, These included an empirical representation
of variations of versus T on each isobar, a self-referencing model developed in our laboratory, a corresponding states model
with one reference, various mixing rules with or without adjustable parameters, a combination of the self-referencing model
and mixing rules, a method based on the Bloomfield and Dewan excess viscosity, and a group contribution method, comparison
of the results showed the self-referencing method to be of particular interest, Moreover when coupled with mixing rules without
adjustable parameters it was able to account satisfactorily for the variations η(P, T, x) of the mixtures, on the simple basis of knowledge if the viscosity of the components of the system, at 25�C and at atmospheric
pressure, For all the binaries an average absolute deviation of 9.5% was observed. Finally it appears that the introduction
of the pressure parameter does not alter the usual performance of each of the models tested, although they were not al equivalent
as regard their performances.