A Study on the Effect of Experience and Effort on Audit Judgment Biases

Yang Mingzeng,Zhang Jixun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2010.02.017

2010-01-01

Abstract:Audit judgment biases are important factors impairing audit quality which affects the stability of capital market.The Belief-adjustment Model predicts that the applicability of the Anchoring and Adjustment Heuristic will lead to judgment bias easily,particularly recency effect and confirmation bias in judgment,which may impair audit quality.The prior studies have focused on experience,task complexity,accountability and review process mitigating recency effect in auditing domains,but all of them do not manipulate the effort of auditor that may mitigate recency effect.This study extends prior related research by examining three levels of experience and two levels of effort in manipulating task complexity.At the same time,the study examines experience and effort on confirmation bias in the complex tasks.In this study,the effects of experience and effort on recency effect are tested by an experiment in a semi-structured task(internal control evaluation) and an unstructured task(going-concern judgment) in the context of Chinese CPAs,and the effects of experience and effort on confirmation bias are tested in the complex task too.The experimental results indicate:(1) In the semi-structured judgment task,the auditors' experience can eliminate recency effect,and the auditors with more experience are less likely to exhibit recency effect;but auditors' effort has no significant influence on recency effect,(2) In the complex unstructured judgment tasks,the auditors' effort has a significant influence on recency effect.The magnitude of recency effect is lower for the auditors with more effort than auditors with less effort;(3) A significant interaction on recency effect between auditors' experience and effort is displayed in the complex unstructured judgment tasks.The more experienced auditors with more effort do not exhibit recency effect,while more experienced auditors with less effort exhibit recency effect.Both no-experienced and low-experienced auditors exhibit significant recency effect,Regardless of effort level;(4) The auditors' experience and effort have no significant effect on confirmation bias in the complex unstructured judgment task.