Comparison of Diagnosis Value of Water's and Panoramic Radiography for Antral Density Change after Mid-Facial Fractures

安金刚,朱丽雷,张益
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-7632.2009.01.008
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate and compare the diagnosis value of Water' and panoramic radiography for antral density change after mid-facial fractures.Methods A retrospective investigation of 115 cases with maxillary sinus wall fractures from 1995 to 2006 was undertaken.A total of 114 cases had preoperative water's and panoramic views and 53 cases had postoperative views.These films were observed by two doctors respectively,then a statistical analysis was made and consistency and reliability of these two kind of films for diagnosis of intra-antrum hemorrhage was compared.Results The statistical result showed that consistency and reliability of Water's view was much better than that of panoramic view.Conclusion Water's and panoramic radiography are still as common radiographic choices for diagnosis of facial fractures.Water's view allows assessment of fractures of maxillary sinus and shows antral density changes very well,but panoramic view can not provide adequate information for intra-antrum hemorrhage.This conclusion is also suitable for sone other diseases with high antral density such as acute or chronic maxillary sinusitis,soft tissue tumor in maxillary sinus.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?