Letter From Our Readers

Yi-fei Qin,Tianmin Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2319/0003-3219-89.3.521
2019-01-01
Abstract:To: Editor, The Angle OrthodontistRe: Accuracy of panoramic radiography in diagnosing maxillary sinus-root relationship: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Wentian Sun, Kai Xia, Li Tang, Chenlu Liu, Ling Zou, Jun Liu. The Angle Orthodontist. 2018;88:819–829.We congratulate the authors for their commendable work on this study. We think there is an anatomical explanation of your conclusions and hope to get your opinion.The main drawback of panoramic radiography is superimposition. When the root is located below the maxillary sinus, the images of the root and the maxillary sinus are nonoverlapping and can be accurately distinguished, just as in your result that panoramic radiography had the highest diagnostic efficiency for type I maxillary sinus-root relationship. When the root is located at the buccal or palatal side of the maxillary sinus, the images of the root and the maxillary sinus overlap each other, and it is difficult to distinguish whether they are projecting into the maxillary sinus. You also reported that the diagnostic efficiency for the type II and III sinus-root relationship is poor and that for the type IV sinus-root relationship, panoramic radiography had a good ability to confirm true type IV but a poor ability to rule out false type IV.Therefore, do you think the accuracy of diagnosing the sinus-root relationship on panoramic radiography is actually an anatomic matter? Some teeth are located below or project into the maxillary sinus more often, and the diagnostic accuracy will be higher. Some teeth are located at the buccal or palatal side of the maxillary sinus more often, and the accuracy will be lower. Do you think this might explain why your result suggested that only the tooth type significantly affected the diagnostic efficacy?Thank you for conducting this important investigation that has raised interesting questions for discussion and suggests new research areas to explore.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?