Abstract:The amendment to the US countervailing duties (CVDs) regulations in 2020 enabled the US government to impose CVDs against currency manipulation, and the first two cases under the new rule are being investigated. Because of the potential wide usage and uncertainty in the lawfulness of imposing CVDs against currency undervaluation, hasty use of them could cause significant controversies in the already fragile WTO regime. This paper examines whether and under what conditions it is permissible to take countervailing measures to counter currency manipulation under the current WTO rules. Unlike most of the prior scholarly analyses, the paper does not confine the analysis only to China’s currency scheme, as the new regulation can apply to almost all exchange rate regimes. This paper addresses multiple legal issues that such a broad scope requires us to examine, including analyses about financial contributions and benefits, two elements of subsidy under the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (ASCM), in relation to different exchange regimes and interventions measures. <br><br>The author concludes that using CVDs against currency manipulation is unlikely justified against usual foreign exchange interventions under floating exchange regimes, whereas it is likely permissible if the target country’s government tightly controls exchange rate transactions under fixed or managed float exchange rate regimes, together with some other conditions. However, from a policy perspective, this paper recommends that WTO Members refrain from using such CVDs against ordinary currency intervention measures to avoid further damaging the international trade regime. WTO Members’ assumed expectation based on the lack of specific mention to currency manipulation in ASCM and the relationship between WTO and the IMF, the potentially huge impact of CVDs based on currency-manipulation subsidies, and the lack of consensus about the method for calculating the amount of undervaluation, call for such self-refrain from a policy standpoint.

Legal Issues on the Alleged RMB Currency Subsidy in the Countervailing Case against Chinese Export Goods in the U.S.——Comment on the Case in which the American Company Nucor Challenges the U.S. Department of Commerce's Decision not to Investigate an Alle

On the Pneumatic OTR Tires Case from a Multilateral Trade Perspective——And Analyze the Judicial Practice of US Anti-Subsidy Law

A Study on the Relationship Between Non-market Economies and Anti-subsidy Law——From the Perspective of the American Anti-subsidy Law

The Legal Analysis on GATT Article 20 Invoked in China's Export Restriction Measures on Various Raw Materials

On the Legal Bases for some Chinese Enterprises against the American Court’s Jurisdiction in the Case of the Extraterritorial Application of American Anti-trust Law——Comment on the Case: American Consumers of Magnesite-based Products Brought Putative Cl

Comment On: US International Trade Court Denied the Motion of Hebei Starbright Tire Co.for Temporary Restraining Order and a Preliminary Injunction in the New Pneumatic Off-The-Road Tires Antidumping and Countervailing Case

The Issue of Non-market Economy Status in China’s Anti-dumping Investigations Against Imports: A Development for the Implementation of New Rules or A Balancing Strategy?

Analysis on the Dispute between China and U.S. over Double Remedies

The Theoretical Sources of NME Rules under the U.S. Trade Remedy Law

Lessons from the Case of Restrictive Exportation of Raw Materials and Reflections on the WTO Exception Rules

New Analysis on Legal Issues of Anti-dumping and Countervailing Launched by the US to Chinese Products under the Financial Crisis

Foreign Exchange Interventions and WTO Subsidy Law: Conditions for Currency Interventions to Be Countervailable

The Reality of China's Subsidy and Legal Approaches to Deal with Foreign Countervailing Measures

The Sino-Foreign Battle for Natural Resources and Countermeasures of China in the WTO: From the Perspective of the Burden of Proof

The Exception on Exhaustible Natural Resources under the WTO Context

Trade Dispute Triggered by Rare Earth and Its Resolution under the WTO

Competitive Neutrality of State-owned Enterprises in China's Steel Industry: A Causal Inference on the Impacts of Subsidies

China’s ‘Going Global’ Policy: Transnational Production Subsidies Under the WTO SCM Agreement

Some Rational Thoughts on the Sino-US Steel Dispute

Case Analysis of USA Anti-dumping to China’s Color TV Sets

Trade Disputes Caused by Export Restrictions on Rare Earths and Its Countermeasures under the WTO Framework