Abstract:R134a will be phased out soon due to its high GWP. Replacing R134a with a low Global Warming Potential (GWP) and non- or slightly flammable fluids in the systems in stock should maintain the same level of system performance. This study focuses on the drop-in alternatives for R134a regarding a Mobile Air-Conditioning system. A simulation model coupled with a microchannel heat exchanger model is developed and validated for calculating the system Coefficient of Performance (COP) and capacity of the Mobile Air-Conditioning system. A comprehensive method is developed to evaluate the alternative candidates combining the performance simulation and the flammability estimated of mixtures. The evaluation includes the system performance, environmental impact, and flammability of alternative mixtures. 15 pairs of binary mixtures from six pure fluids (R134a, R1234yf, R1234ze(E), R32, R227ea, and R152a) with 99 compositions are evaluated as R134a drop-in replacements, and the results are discussed. There is no perfect mixture found that is nonflammable, has low GWP, and has higher system efficiency and capacity than R134a in this study. Using R152a as a drop-in replacement of R134a can increase the system efficiency and capacity, but R152a is flammable. By adding R134a or R227ea to R152a can reduce the flammability of the mixture. R152a/R134a, R152a/R1234yf, and R32/R152a have higher COP and capacity than R134a, but they are not safe or environmental friendly enough. The mixtures for replacing R134a as drop-in alternatives with low Global Warming Potential (less than 150 or 700), nonflammable or slightly flammable are listed and discussed. The method developed in this study can be extended to evaluate alternatives for replacing other working fluids in any thermal application that will be restricted.

Cost analysis on replacement of R22 with R410A

A Comprehensive Study of Drop-in Alternative Mixtures for R134a in a Mobile Air-Conditioning System

Experimental study on the cycle performance of refrigerant R32

Evaluation on Cycle Performance of R161 As a Drop-in Replacement for R407C in Small-Scale Air Conditioning Systems

Re-analysis on Using R32 to Substitute for R22 in Household/commercial Air-conditioning

Experimental study of ternary mixture R32/R125/R161 as alternative refrigerant to R407C

Review of the Application of R32 on Air Conditioners and Heat Pump Systems

Influence of cost on system optimization of R22 alternative refrigerants

THE CALCULATION AND COMPARISON OF THERMAL PATAMETERS ON R22 AND SUBSTITUATION

Simulations and experiments of substitution of R41 for R23 in auto-cascade refrigeration cycle with rectifying column at -60℃

Analysis on exergy of refrigeration system using R32 to substitute R22

Evaporative Characteristics of Air-conditioners System with Refrigerant R410A Replacing R22

Performance analysis of substitutes of R22 for the regenerative cycle

Exploration of using R32 to substitute for R22 in household/commercial air-conditioning

Energy performance assessment of R1243zf/R134a, R1243zf/RE170, and R1243zf/R227ea as possible alternatives to R410A refrigerant in precision air conditioning unit

Experimental Researches on Air Conditioner System of R410A

Optimization Analyses on the Performance of an Auto-Cascade Absorption Refrigeration System Operating with Mixed Refrigerants

Theoretical and Experimental Research on the Performance of Twin Screw Compressor Using R513A As R134a Replacement

Theoretical Analysis and Experimental Study on Hydrocarbons to Replace R134a in Car Air Conditioners

Recent Research on Air Conditioner System and Heat Exchanger of R407C

Study on Refrigerant Alternation for Reciprocating Refrigeration Compressor