On the Limitations of Collective-identifying Theory Advanced by Habermas

WANG Yi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-1505.2013.02.006
2013-01-01
Abstract:Using Post-nationalism and Constitutional Patriotism as two theoretical framework,Habermas put forward collective-identifying theory on the background of German reunification,the European Union,immigration wave and globalization.Reviewing the history,investigating the present,and looking forward to the future,Habermas believes that the establishment of modern European Political Community should breakthrough national identification,replace nationalism with Constitutional Patriotism,in order to adapt to the cultural diversity of modern society.However,can post-nationalism bloom and bear fruit in this deeply-rooted nationalism land? Is a supranational European Community desirable? Can the constitution patriotism which is dedicated to the construction of European identity be feasible? Since the theory was put forward,the discussion is never end,and the comments are differing.This article reviews that both post-nationalism and the Constitution Patriotism have some theoretical defects in a certain extent,and are bound to encounter inevitable challenges in the political practice.Habermas's theories are built on the vacuum between Norms and reality,doomed to lose foundation on either side.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?