A Review and Integration of Research on Blind and Constructive Patriotism

Robert T. Schatz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-30534-9_30-1

2018-01-01

Abstract:This chapter examines theory and research on “blind” and “constructive” patriotismPatriotismblind. Blind patriotismBlind patriotism is characterized by staunch and unquestioning allegiance to the nation and rejection of ingroup criticism. Constructive patriotismPatriotismconstructiveConstructive patriotism is characterized by critical loyalty, questioning, and criticism of current group practices that are intended to better the nation. The two patriotic orientations represent distinct modes of ingroup identification and allegiance that predict different attitudes toward outgroupsOutgroup. Individuals high in blind patriotism fuse their personal identity with their social identitySocial identity as an ingroup member. They are motivated to evaluate national attributes favorably to maintain positive group identity. Blind patriotism is rooted in symbolic attachmentSymbolic attachment to an idealized image of the nation. It engenders exclusive group boundaries, negative attitudes toward outgroups, and refusal to acknowledge the nation’s transgressions against others. Individuals high in constructive patriotism gain positive identity from group membership while maintaining personal independence and a capacity to stand apart from the group. They are motivated to evaluate national attributes realistically to identify and correct the group’s shortcomings. Constructive patriotism is rooted in instrumental attachmentInstrumental attachment to the nation’s systems and institutions. It engenders relatively inclusive group boundaries and positive attitudes toward outgroups and willingness to take responsibility for the nation’s transgressions against others.I would like to thank Steve Glickman and Linda Arons for their helpful feedback on an earlier version of this manuscript.