Abstract:"Q Zhang's Problem" is a teaching problem proposed by Qian Zhang, a science teacher at Dongjiao Minxiang Primary School in Dongcheng District, Beijing. In 2022, she proposed that: (1) when explaining the knowledge points of frequency in the "Sound" unit, experiments on the vibration of objects such as rubber bands and steel rulers were used to assist students in learning, but the effect was not obvious, because it was difficult for the naked eye to distinguish the speed of vibration of objects such as rubber bands, and it was difficult to correspond to the high and low frequencies; (2) Students seem to be confused about the difference between frequency and amplitude. When guiding them to make the rubber band vibrate faster, they tend to tug harder at the rubber band, but this actually changes the amplitude rather than the frequency (changing the frequency should be to control its vibrating chord length, similar to the tuning method of a stringed instrument). Therefore, demonstration experiments using objects such as rubber bands as frequencies do not seem suitable and cannot effectively assist students in establishing the concept of frequency. We hope to solicit opinions and solutions (research ideas) on this problem, with a focus on two points: (1) the mathematical/physical explanation of the problem. That is, does simply changing the amplitude really not affect the original vibration frequency of the object (except when the amplitude is 0) (2) explanation from a cognitive perspective: Why do people confuse the two concepts? What is the cognitive mechanism behind it.

Experimental problem and solution of the 9~(th) Asia Physics Olympiad

Experimental problem and solution of the 10~(th) Asia Physics Olympiad

Investigation on phenomena of frequency transition in thermoacoustic system

Experimental Demonstration Of Acoustic Inversion Using An Auv Carrying Source

Experimental Study On A Standing-Wave Thermoacoustic Engine Driving An Rc Load Through Acoustic Pressure Amplifier

Study of Acoustic Tomography Based on Data Assimilation for Shallow Water Environments

Polynomial Solutions to Piezoelectric Beams (ii)—analytical Solutions to Typical Problems

Ocean Acoustic Tomography As a Data Assimilation Problem

Building the Isotropic Acoustic Potential Well with Strong Constraint Boundary to Improve the Stability of Ultrasonic Transportation

Introduction of Acoustics Laboratory, Department of Physics,Tsinghua University

Problem and solution of the 40th IPhO experiment test

Optimization methods for acoustic performance of piezoelectric panel loudspeaker.

Photoacoustic Measurement of Sound Speed in Solid Medium

Comprehensive experiment of ultrasonic testing

A potpourri of homework and test problems inspired by published research and/or classroom demonstrations

Soliciting opinions and solutions on the "Q Zhang's Problem"

The method of fundamental solutions for the high frequency acoustic-elastic problem and its relationship to a pure acoustic problem

Problems and Solutions of the 39th IPhO Experiment Test

Acoustic Suspension Phenomenon

Topology Optimization Design Method for Acoustic Imaging Array of Power Equipment

Numerical Study of Sound Pressure Distribution in Volume Determination with Acoustic Method