The cryogenic system for ITER CC superconducting conductor test facility
Jinqing Peng,Yu Wu,Huajun Liu,Yi Shi,Jinglin Chen,Zhibin Ren
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cryogenics.2010.11.004
IF: 2.134
2011-01-01
Cryogenics
Abstract:This paper describes the cryogenic system of the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) Correction Coils (CC) test facility, which consists of a 500 W/4.5 K helium refrigerator, a 50 kA superconducting transformer cryostat (STC) and a background field magnet cryostat (BFMC). The 500 W/4.5 K helium refrigerator synchronously produces both the liquid helium (LHe) and supercritical helium (SHe). The background field magnet and the primary coil of the superconducting transformer (PCST) are cooled down by immersing into 4.2 K LHe. The secondary Cable-In-Conduit Conductor (CICC) coil of the superconducting transformer (SCST), superconducting joints and the testing sample of ITER CC are cooled down by forced-flow supercritical helium. During the commissioning experiment, all the superconducting coils were successfully translated into superconducting state. The background field magnet was fully cooled by immersing it into 4.2 K LHe and generated a maximal background magnetic field of 6.96 T; the temperature of transformer coils and current leads was reduced to 4.3 K; the inlet temperature of SHe loop was 5.6 K, which can meet the cooling requirements of CIC-Conductor and joint boxes. It is noted that a novel heat cut-off device for High Temperature Superconducting (HTS) binary current leads was introduced to reduce the heat losses of transformer cryostat. Keywords Cryogenic system Superconducting conductor Cryostat Helium refrigerator Supercritical helium 1 Introduction International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) is an experimental tokamak (magnetic confinement fusion) research project which aims to demonstrate that it is possible to produce commercial energy from fusion to meet the humankind’s future energy requirement [1] . ITER project is one of the largest international-cooperation scientific experiments in the world, which is proceeding in the engineering construction phase. ITER CC (Correction Coils), one types of superconducting coils of ITER device, are used to compensate field errors which arisen from misalignment of the coils and winding deviations from the nominal shape caused by fabrication tolerances, distortion tolerances and assembly tolerances. There are 18 multi-turn correction coils, consisting of six top CC, six bottom CC and six side CC. The ITER CC are made of Cable-In-Conduit Conductor (CICC), fabricated by multistage sub-cable of NbTi superconducting strand, and would be cooled by supercritical helium. According to its procurement arrangement, ITER CC conductor will be produced and subjected to dedicated test in China. Therefore, a large superconducting conductor test facility with large current (50 kA) and high magnetic field (7 T), known as ITER CC test facility, has been built recently in the Institute of Plasma Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences (ASIPP) [2] . The primary objective of the CC conductor sample test is to properly assess the critical performance of current and temperature ( I C , T CS ) of the tested conductors under the simulation operating conditions and to confirm whether the tested conductor meets the ITER CC’s performance requirements. ITER CC test facility mainly consists of cryogenic system, background magnet, current superconducting transformer, conductor short sample cryostat, power supply system, vacuum pumping system, control and data acquisition system and instrumentations [3] (see Fig. 1 ). The peak field provided by background magnet could reach to 6.96 T at 4.2 K. The current superconducting transformer could supply 50 kA current for the test facility [4] . This paper is concerned with design and construction of the cryogenic system of ITER CC test facility. As an important part of this test facility, the helium cryogenic system must be able to provide adequate flow rate, pressure, and refrigeration capacity to cool down and maintain all the magnets and conductors in superconducting state under normal operating conditions. This paper firstly presents the overall structure of the cryogenic system and the design of the cooling loop based on the required cooling temperature, helium pressure and mass flow rates of different superconducting magnets. As a main work, the detailed structural design of the superconducting transformer cryostat is described. It is noted that in order to reduce the heat losses of transformer cryostat, a novel heat cut-off device for HTS binary current leads was introduced in this paper. Finally, the commissioning experiment results are achieved and analyzed. 2 The design of cryogenic system The cryogenic system of ITER CC test facility mainly consists of a 500 W/4.5 K helium refrigerator, a 50 kA current superconducting transformer cryostat (STC) and a 7 T background field magnet cryostat (BFMC) (see Fig. 2 ). The 500 W/4.5 K helium refrigerator is connected with the STC and BFMC by transmission pipelines. It is mainly used for producing 4.2 K liquid helium (LHe) to immerse and cool down the background field magnet and the primary coil of the superconducting transformer (PCST). In addition, it can also supply the forced-flow supercritical helium (SHe) of 4.5 K/3.5 bar to cool down the secondary coil of superconducting transformer (SCST) and the ITER CC conductor sample. The design parameters of the cryogenic system are presented in Table 1 . The distribution of LHe and SHe in the test facility is shown in Fig. 3 . 2.1 500 W/4.5 K helium refrigerator The 500 W/4.5 K helium refrigerator adopts Collins helium liquefaction cycle and possesses of four cooling stages as follows: liquid nitrogen pre-cooling, the first stage expansion (including three piston expanders), the second stage expansion (one piston expander) and J – T valve throttle cooling. The original nominal cooling capacity of this refrigerator was approximately equivalent to 500 W at 4.5 K, and it could provide 4.5–6 K, 2.5–5 bar, 20–40 g/s SHe for magnets or 150 L/h helium liquefying capability [5] . However, as this refrigerator has been in service for 30 years, the cooling capacity has been seriously degenerated. Particularly the efficiency reduction of piston expanders caused that the outlet temperature of refrigerator is too high. It was about 5.3 K @ 3.0 bar during last commissioning experiment. In fact, we are planning to build a new helium refrigerator with 1000 W @ 4.2 K capacity to cope with this problem. The existing 500 W/4.5 K cryogenic system shares the same compressors unit with EAST Tokamak cryogenic system, to which seven sets of oil injection type screw compressors are applied. 2.2 Background field magnet cryostat The background field magnet cryostat (BFMC) was originally used to serve the CEA test facility for testing TORUS II conductors and then presented to ASIPP in 2003. We have rebuilt this device after many improvements were done in the cooling, power supply, data measurement and acquisition, magnet quench protection system, etc. [6] . The scheme of BFMC is shown in Fig. 4 . This cryostat features a DC background field up to 7 T in a 338 mm useful bore diameter [7,8] . When it is used for ITER CC short sample test, the sample anti-cryostat needs to be inserted into the 338 mm bore of the background magnet. 2.3 50 kA current superconducting transformer cryostat In the test facility, the 50 kA current is supplied by a current superconducting transformer which was immersed into a superconducting transformer cryostat (STC) by LHe. This transformer is comprised of two coaxial coils, named primary coil and secondary coil respectively. The primary coil was wound into solenoid coil by single NbTi superconducting strand and was placed in a cylindrical transformer LHe vessel [9] . The secondary coil, fixed to the outer surface of the transformer LHe vessel, was fabricated by CIC-Conductor for transmitting 50 kA large current. And it was cooled by 4.5 K/3.5 bar SHe. To maintain the superconductivity of the superconducting transformer, a cryostat was required. This cryostat was assembled at the top of BFMC by vertical flange coupling. From the bottom to the top, it mainly consists of two LHe vessels, High Temperature Superconducting (HTS) current leads, LN 2 vessel, heat cut-off device of current leads (HCDCL) and thermal shields (see Fig. 5 ). The superconducting transformer LHe vessel was used to immerse and cool down the primary coil into 4.2 K. The upper LHe storage vessel was applied to store helium and then supply LHe to the transformer LHe vessel. Therefore, the primary coil could be sufficiently cooled during operating period. Above the LHe storage vessel, there is a LN 2 vessel, which was used to cool the copper thermal shields and HCDCL. To decrease the evaporation of LHe, HTS current leads with 200 A nominal current, instead of common copper current leads, were used for charging the primary coil [9] . As a result, the heat loads was reduced to 0.13 W, much less than copper current leads’. Under the operating conditions, the upper end of the HTS current leads were indirectly cooled by liquid nitrogen through the HCDCL and its temperature maintains at about 80 K. The lower end connected to the current terminal of the primary coil was immersed by 4.2 K LHe. The novel heat cut-off device of current leads (HCDCL) (see Fig. 6 ), cooled directly by liquid nitrogen, was applied to cut-off the heat flow of current leads. As shown in Fig. 6 , in the central part of LN 2 vessel, a copper heating conducting plate (CHCP) was installed and welded with the circular inner wall of LN 2 vessel. The circumference side of CHCP can directly contact with the LN 2 , so CHCP can be fully cooled by LN 2 . Thus the heat loads caused by common copper current leads will be cut-off by CHCP. In addition, between the CHCP and the copper current leads, there are some pieces of aluminium nitride (AlN) to play the role of electric insulation and heat transfer. Therefore the cooling capacity of LN 2 can be indirectly transferred to the copper current leads and the upper end of HTS current leads via the CHCP and AlN pieces. Meantime, the HCDCL can make full use of the cold capacity of helium gas, which evaporated from LHe vessel and can pass through the cut-off device by reserved channels. HCDCL can enhance the stability and security of HTS current leads. In addition, it also can reduce the heat loads caused by heat conducting of current leads, measurement wires and cryostat neck. The thermal shields are to ensure the temperature variation is within 5 K at the given heat loads. The external surface of the shields was covered with multi-layer super-insulation blanket. After calculation, the theoretical results of the heat loads and helium evaporation rate of the transformer cryostat are 5.84 W, 8.6 L/h respectively. 2.4 The closed circuit for short sample testing As shown in Fig. 2 , the transformer cryostat was connected with the sample test anti-cryostat by an interface flange for sealing. The lower end of the anti-cryostat where the ITER CC short sample is located was inserted into the bore of the background magnet. Two legs of the transformer secondary coil were extended to the anti-cryostat by crossing the interface flange and connected with the ITER CC short sample via CICC superconducting joints [9] . Therefore, the secondary coil, CC conductor short sample and superconducting joints comprised a closed current circuit (see Fig. 7 ). Based on this, the target of charging the ITER CC short sample with 50 kA large current induced from the secondary coil was achieved. Besides, there are cooling channels in the joints reserved for SHe cooling the CIC-Conductors of secondary coil and short sample as well as superconducting joints themselves. 3 Cooling procedure of the cryogenic system Before the liquid nitrogen was supplied to the LN 2 vessels and cooled the thermal shields of all cryostats, a vacuum pumping system had been initially used to bring all cryostats’ pressure below 10 −3 Pa. Once the refrigerator was activated, the helium vessels of transformer cryostat and He baths of background magnet cryostat were pre-cooled by cold helium gaseous with forced circulation. To avoid extra thermal stress damage to magnets, when the temperature of magnets is higher than 100 K, the maximal temperature difference between output and input gas should not exceed 30 K. When the temperature is lower than 10 K, another refrigerator operation mode should be switched to, in which the 4.2 K LHe was produced and then supplied to the helium vessels and He baths. After these vessels were filled with LHe, such a refrigerator operation mode should be adopted, in which the 4.5 K/3.5 bar SHe was produced and the valves of SHe cooling loops were turned on and then SHe entered into and cooled down the CIC-Conductors of secondary coil and ITER CC short sample as well as superconducting joints. While the LHe of the helium vessels and He baths is not sufficient, it can be supplemented through the flow control valves throttling SHe into LHe. That is to say this cryogenic system can supply LHe and SHe simultaneously by self-designed valves external throttling. Fig. 8 shows the flow chart of cryogenic system. The helium coolant was divided into two streams before injected into test facility, i.e. 4.5 K/3.5 bar SHe and 4.2 K LHe. 1. 4.5 K/3.5 bar SHe : just as ① – ① loop shows in Fig. 8 , supplying the forced-flow SHe to cool down the secondary coil of transformer, the ITER CC test sample and CICC joint boxes. 2. 4.2 K LHe : just as ② – ② loop and ③ – ③ loop shows in Fig. 8 , taking advantage of the throttle function of self-designed low-temperature valve, one can attain 4.2 K LHe and use it to immerse the background magnet and the primary coil of superconducting transformer. 4 Experiments and discussion The cryogenic commissioning experiment for the ITER CC test facility has been conducted. Fig. 9 shows the cooling down curve of ITER CC test facility. Based on the experiment, a number of important results were obtained and a few conclusions were reached as well: (1) The background magnet was fully cooled by LHe immersion and generated a maximal magnetic field of 6.96 T under the maximal charging current of 1000 A. (2) The temperature of superconducting transformer magnets and current leads was reduced to 4.3 K and the inlet temperature of supercritical helium was 5.6 K. Although the 5.6 K SHe can cool down the CIC-Conductors and joint boxes and maintain their superconductivity, it is too high for real tests of ITER CC. After carefully reviewing the experimental data, it was found that two main reasons contributed to the higher temperature of SHe. Firstly, as this refrigerator has been in service for 30 years, the efficiency reduction of piston expanders resulted in higher outlet temperature of refrigerator. On the other hand, the design of existing transfer lines was unreasonable, thus lead to large heat leakage. The existing transfer lines were common evacuated transfer lines. The heat leakage of this kind of transfer lines is about 1.5 W/m. Therefore, for 40 m transfer lines, the heat loss is about 60 W. In order to cope with these two issues, we are planning to build a new 1000 W @ 4.2 K refrigerator and design a new type of transfer line which can make full use of the cold capacity of helium return gas, so the heat leakage will be reduced greatly. When the above two issues are effectively resolved, it is expected to achieve the goal that the inlet temperature of SHe is below 4.5 K. (3) The temperature of HTS upper end and heat cut-off device stayed at 80 K. It can be concluded that the heat cut-off device played a significant role in cutting heat flow and reducing heat loads. (4) The real helium evaporation rate of the transformer cryostat is 9.5 L/h, a bit higher than the calculated value (8.6 L/h). The nitrogen evaporation rate of the transformer cryostat is 2.5 L/h, higher than the designed value (2.1 L/h). (5) The goal is achieved that the helium refrigerator synchronously provides LHe and SHe by throttling SHe into LHe. (6) During the cryogenic commissioning experiment, the current in the primary coil of transformer was charged from 0 to 150 A, increasing at the rate of 80 A/min. The current induced in the secondary coil loop increased from 0 to 58 kA, higher than the designed value (50 kA). 5 Conclusions The cryogenic system of ITER CC test facility was manufactured and tested in ASIPP. The helium refrigerator successfully achieved the goal of synchronously providing LHe and SHe for different superconducting coils and magnets. The structure of the overall cryogenic system is proper and effective. The background magnet generated a maximal magnetic field of 6.96 T under the maximal charging current of 1000 A. As for the transformer cryostat, the temperature of transformer magnets and current leads was reduced to 4.3 K and the inlet temperature of SHe was 5.6 K, which met the cooling requirements of CIC-Conductors and joint boxes. The heat cut-off device of the transformer cryostat stayed at 80 K during the operation period and played a significant role in cutting heat flow and reducing heat loads. The real helium evaporation rate of the transformer cryostat is 9.5 L/h, a bit higher than the calculated value of 8.6 L/h. All the experiment results prove that the design of the cryogenic system is successful and suitable for the ITER CC test facility. The results in accordance with the design will take a milestone step on the way to the ITER CC project. After a series of successful commissioning and pre-tests, a thorough acceptance test program will be conducted. It is expected that the acceptance test will be passed and the ITER CC test facility will be ready for real tests as soon as possible. Acknowledgments The work described in this paper was supported by the Instrument Developing Project of the Chinese Academy of Sciences with Grant No.: Yz200726. All the work described above has been accomplished by the Applied Superconductivity Group of ASIPP. The authors appreciate their great efforts. The authors also would like to thank Mr. Qin Jinggang and Mr. Zhou Chao for valuable suggestions. References [1] <http://www.iter.org/proj> (September 2010). [2] Wu Y. Preliminary electromagnetic analysis of correction coils for ITER. Unpublished results; August 2008. [3] H.J. Liu Y. Wu Y. Shi The design of test facility for ITER CC conductor IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 20 3 2010 1973 1976 [4] Y. Shi Y. Wu S.T. Wu The 50 kA superconducting transformer for testing ITER CC conductors short sample IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 20 3 2010 1155 1158 [5] Y. Wu P.D. Weng The test facility for the EAST superconducting magnets Plasma Sci Technol 7 4 2005 2919 2922 [6] H.J. Liu Y. Wu J.L. Chen Test of a NbTi 7 T superconducting magnet Cryogen Supercond 37 3 2009 24 26 [in Chinese] [7] J.L. Augueres R. Aymar G. Bon Mardion 700 mm diameter cryostats operating at 1.8 K and atmospheric pressure Cryogenics 20 9 1980 529 533 [8] R. Aymar P. Genevey S. Palanque A NbTi 10 T 388 mm bore magnet working at 1.8 K in pressurized superfluid helium Cryogenics 20 9 1980 521 524 [9] H.J. Liu Y. Wu Z.B. Ren Manufacturing of 50 kA superconducting transformer for ITER correction coil conductor test Rev Sci Instrum 81 044701 2010 1 3