Abstract:Argumentation is a fundamental communicative ability that children develop over time through formal schooling and daily practice with peers and family members. Literature on children's argumentation appears to have focused on their social interactions out of school, clinical environment, or informal pedagogic contexts. Even though there are research inquiries into children’s argumentation in formal academic learning, many have been focused on argumentative writing in math or science classes. Much less is known about teacher-led argumentation and the youngest children's emerging argumentation in language art classes, where argumentation is formally and systematically introduced and learned. This paper reports a year-long ethnographic study on argumentation in a first-grade English language art classroom in the United States. Ethnographic discourse analysis was conducted to analyze two key literacy events from the daily reader's and writer's workshop. It is supplemented with qualitative analysis of the researchers' field notes and the students' artifacts. Our findings highlight the inherent intertextual nature of children’s argumentation and a critical role the teacher played in eliciting and steering the children’s argumentation construction through strategic instructional conversations (especially accountable talk). Our findings also revealed teacher-led children’s intertextual argumentation as a powerful heuristic process and tool to enrich students’ learning. The paper concludes some classroom argumentation teaching practices based on the research findings.

An Argumentation for the Rationality of Educational Scholar's Intervention into Practice

Self-judgment and Discernment:A Reflection On the Precondition of Educational Scholars Participating into School Transformation

Educational Scholars' Responsibility of Participating in Practice Reform

On the Methodology of Educational Researchers' Intervening into Practice:The Reflection and Reconstruction of the Creed of "insider" and "Outsider"

On the Life Style and Research Standpoint of Educational Researcher in a Professional Context

A Study on the Role and Attitude of the Education Researchers for Practice

On the Plight Caused by the Institutalization of Educational Research and its Outlet

On Bildsamkeit and Education： from Herbart to Benner

On Participatory Educational Research and Its Value Promise

Reconsidering the Problem of Disciplinary Boundaries in Education:Educational Thought on the Interdisciplinary Research

Reinterpretation of the Disciplinery Independence of Pedagogy

Practical Reasoning of University Teachers’Understanding of Being a“Good Teacher”:The Process of a Grounded Theory Study and Its Reflection

Studies On"schools of Future":Consensus,Controversies and Potential Risks

Reasoning in Social Settings

A Study on the University Teachers' Practical Reasoning from the Chinese Socio-Cultural Perspective

Exploring young children’s argumentation as a heuristic intertextual practice

Integrating Individual Preferences into Collective Argumentation

Criticizing and Introspecting on Public School's "Bureaucracy Criticism"

Pragma-Dialectics: from a Perspective of Critical Thinking

Moral Education Through the Fostering of Reasoning Skills

On the Logic of Education Practice