Abstract:Diverse emergent correlated electron phenomena have been observed in twisted graphene layers due to electronic interactions with the moiré superlattice potential. Many electronic structure predictions have been reported exploring this new field, but with few momentum-resolved electronic structure measurements to test them. Here we use angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) to study the twist-dependent ($1^\circ < \theta < 8^\circ$) electronic band structure of few-layer graphenes, including twisted bilayer, monolayer-on-bilayer, and double-bilayer graphene (tDBG). Direct comparison is made between experiment and theory, using a hybrid $\textbf{k}\cdot\textbf{p}$ model for interlayer coupling and implementing photon-energy-dependent phase shifts for photo-electrons from consecutive layers to simulate ARPES spectra. Quantitative agreement between experiment and theory is found across twist angles, stacking geometries, and back-gate voltages, validating the models and revealing displacement field induced gap openings in twisted graphenes. However, for tDBG at $\theta=1.5\pm0.2^\circ$, close to the predicted magic-angle of $\theta=1.3^\circ$, a flat band is found near the Fermi-level with measured bandwidth of $E_w = 31\pm5$ meV. Analysis of the gap between the flat band and the next valence band shows significant deviations between experiment ($\Delta_h=46\pm5$meV) and the theoretical model ($\Delta_h=5$meV), indicative of the importance of lattice relaxation in this regime.

Low Energy Excitations in Graphite: the Role of Dimensionality and Lattice Defects

Coexistence of Sharp Quasiparticle Dispersions and Disorder Features in Graphite

First Direct Observation of Dirac Fermions in Graphite

Disparate Exciton-Phonon Couplings for Zone-Center and Boundary Phonons in Solid-State Graphite

Departure from the Conical Dispersion in Epitaxial Graphene

Excitation Spectrum and High-Energy Plasmons in Single-Layer and Multilayer Graphene

One-Dimensional Energy Dispersion of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes by Resonant Electron Scattering

Fingerprints of Disorder Source in Graphene

Evidence for Disorder Induced Delocalization in Graphite

Sublattice symmetry breaking and ultra low energy excitations in Graphene-on-hBN Heterostructures

The electronic structure of epitaxial graphene—A view from angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy

Graphene: from materials science to particle physics

ARPES signatures of few-layer twistronic graphenes

The phonon dispersion of graphite revisited

Ultrafast momentum-resolved visualization of the interplay between phonon-mediated scattering and plasmons in graphite

Electronic excitations and electron-phonon coupling in bulk graphite through Raman scattering in high magnetic fields

Interfacial electron-phonon coupling and quantum confinement in ultrathin Yb films on graphite

Experimental Determination of Electron Transition Probabilities in Elementary Electron-Phonon Scattering Processes Using Electron-Energy-Loss Spectroscopy: The Example of Graphite

Flat Bands Near Fermi Level Of Topological Line Defects On Graphite

Van Hove Singularities, Chemical Pressure and Phonons: an Angle-Resolved Photoemission Study of KFe_2As_2 and CsFe_2As_2

A Density Functional Theory Study of Ground and Low-Lying Excited Electronic States in Defective Graphenes