One-Dimensional Energy Dispersion of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes by Resonant Electron Scattering

Min Ouyang,Jin-Lin Huang,Charles M. Lieber
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.88.066804
2001-07-28
Abstract:We characterized the energy band dispersion near the Fermi level in single-walled carbon nanotubes using low-temperature scanning tunneling microscopy. Analysis of energy dependent standing wave oscillations, which result from quantum interference of electrons resonantly scattered by defects, yield a linear energy dispersion near EF, and indicate the importance of parity in scattering for armchair single-walled carbon nanotubes. Additionally, these data provide values of the tight-binding overlap integral and Fermi wavevector in good agreement with previous work, but indicate that the electron coherence length is substantially shortened.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **To experimentally determine the energy dispersion characteristics of single - walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) near the Fermi level, especially the characteristics of their linear energy dispersion**. Specifically, the author hopes to experimentally verify the unique linear energy dispersion relationship of single - walled carbon nanotubes predicted by theory under one - dimensional conditions. ### Background and Problem 1. **Theoretical Prediction**: - For isolated chiral (n,n) single - walled carbon nanotubes, the π - bonding (π) and π - antibonding (π*) bands intersect linearly near the Fermi level (\(E_F\)), which is different from the parabolic dependence in the traditional free - electron model. 2. **Experimental Challenges**: - Traditional momentum analysis methods are difficult to apply to single - walled carbon nanotubes because these samples contain multiple structures, each with different energy dispersion. - Previous studies lack experimental verification of this important property. ### Solution The author used a low - temperature scanning tunneling microscope (STM) to study the energy - dependent standing - wave oscillations near defects in single - walled carbon nanotubes. By analyzing the quantum interference effect, they were able to directly measure the energy dispersion near the Fermi level and verify its linear characteristics. ### Main Findings 1. **Linear Energy Dispersion**: - The experimental results show that near the Fermi level, the energy dispersion of single - walled carbon nanotubes exhibits a linear relationship, which is in line with theoretical predictions. - Using the formula \(|E(k)|=\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}a\gamma_0|k - k_F|\), where \(a\) is the armchair lattice constant, \(\gamma_0\) is the tight - binding overlap integral, and \(k_F\) is the Fermi wave vector, fitting the experimental data gives \(\gamma_0 = 2.51 \, \text{eV}\) and \(k_F=8.48\pm0.05 \, \text{nm}^{-1}\). 2. **Parity Effect of Scattering**: - The study shows that in chiral (n,n) single - walled carbon nanotubes, the scattering process is very sensitive to parity. For defects with odd parity, only electrons in the π* band (odd parity) can be scattered, while electrons in the π band (even parity) will not be scattered. 3. **Coherent Length and Phase Shift**: - The analysis results show that the electron coherent length \(l_\phi\) is significantly shortened, with an average value of \(1.89\pm0.27 \, \text{nm}\), indicating a high phase - randomizing scattering rate. - The average scattering phase shift \(\delta\) is \(- 3.57\pm0.13\) and \(-2.06\pm0.16\) above and below the Fermi level respectively, indicating a net repulsive interaction between the defect and the electron. ### Conclusion This study directly verified the linear energy dispersion characteristics of single - walled carbon nanotubes near the Fermi level experimentally for the first time and revealed the importance of parity in the scattering process. These findings not only deepen the understanding of the electronic structure of single - walled carbon nanotubes but also provide important basic data for future applications.