Introduction of a modified QTBM model for predicting TBM penetration rate in rock, based on data from mechanized tunneling projects in Iran

Jafar Hassanpour,Chamran Kazemi,Jamal Rostami
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10064-024-03659-0
IF: 4.2
2024-04-11
Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment
Abstract:One of the TBM performance prediction models that has been introduced in recent years and used for estimating penetration rate of TBM in hard rock conditions is the Q TBM model. This model was introduced by Barton in the early 2000s. There have been many reviews of this model and the estimated penetration rates in various projects. This study was also conducted to check the validity of this model and propose modifications to models for different geological conditions. For this purpose, a database of TBM field performance along with geological information was prepared from 109 tunnel sections (with reliable geological and machine data). The results of calculated penetration rate by the Q TBM model were compared with the field observation in the database. The results showed that this model offers low accuracy in predicting the machine penetration rate in different geological conditions. Subsequently, the relationship between input parameters of the Q TBM model with the penetration rate was re-examined to see the impact of individual input parameters on the penetration rate of the machine. A new model is proposed, where the input parameters with lower impact on the penetration rate were removed and an attempt was made to obtain an empirical relationship between the more influential parameters and the field penetration index (FPI). New empirical relationships are more accurate in predicting machine penetration rates due to their simplicity and the need for fewer input data.
engineering, environmental,geosciences, multidisciplinary, geological
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the low accuracy of the existing QTBM model in predicting the penetration rate of Tunnel Boring Machines (TBM) under different geological conditions. Specifically: 1. **Limitations of the existing model**: The paper points out that although the QTBM model can provide useful predictions under certain conditions, its complexity and dependence on multiple input parameters lead to insufficient prediction accuracy in practical applications. In particular, the relationships between some input parameters and the machine's penetration rate are unclear or have little impact, such as groundwater conditions (Jw), in - situ stress and induced stress (SIGMAcm), rock abrasiveness (CLI), etc. 2. **Data verification**: The author constructed a data set containing 109 tunnel segments by collecting TBM on - site performance data from three long - distance water conveyance tunnel projects in Iran (Karaj, Ghomrood and Zagros/Nowsood projects). These data were used to verify the prediction results of the QTBM model and compare them with the actual observed values. 3. **Model improvement**: The study found that the QTBM model has a large error in predicting the TBM penetration rate under different geological conditions. Therefore, the author re - evaluated the influence of each input parameter in the model on the penetration rate and proposed a new simplified model. The new model removed the parameters with less influence and attempted to establish an empirical relationship between key parameters (such as rock strength, joint spacing, etc.) and the Field Penetration Index (FPI). 4. **Objective**: Through the above research, the paper aims to propose a new, simpler and more accurate model to improve the reliability of TBM penetration rate prediction, especially under different geological conditions. ### Key point summary: - **Problem**: The QTBM model has low prediction accuracy under different geological conditions. - **Method**: By collecting actual project data, verify the prediction results of the QTBM model and analyze the influence of each input parameter. - **Result**: A new simplified model was proposed, which improved the prediction accuracy. - **Significance**: Provide more reliable technical support for TBM construction and optimize construction efficiency and safety. Hope this summary can help you understand the core problems and research purposes of the paper. If you need further information or specific formula explanations, please feel free to let us know!