Balancing the evidential scales for the mental unconscious

Aliya R. Dewey
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09515089.2024.2316837
2024-02-11
Philosophical Psychology
Abstract:1. This is a penultimate draft. Please cite the version that is forthcoming in Philosophical Psychology . 2. There is a potential problem here. If blindsight is an unfavorable condition for subjective reporting in the relevant sense, then there are no favorable conditions for subjective reporting in blindsight patients and it is impossible to justify attributions of either consciousness or unconsciousness to blind sight patients. The same problem will be present for consciousness in any other health condition that affects reportability. This seems to be a difficult problem, but I don't think it's reason to reject the favorability proviso that N&S seem to advocate for reportability accounts of unconsciousness. Rather, I think it's better treated as an open problem that warrants constructive philosophical attention. I thank Reviewer 1 for raising this issue.
psychology, multidisciplinary,ethics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?