Abstract:One of the major challenges facing the science of consciousness today is to provide an explanatory framework that accounts for both the subjectivity and neurobiology of consciousness,which is triggered by the difficult problem of consciousness.The distinction between the "hard problem" and the "easy problem" of consciousness is put forward by Chalmers.Easy problems are those which explain cognitive and behavioral functions,and can be resolved by the traditional approach to consciousness study.However, effective research methods which are to explain conscious experiences accompanying cognitive and behavioral functions need to be developed to deal with hard problems.In order to provide a methodological remedy for the hard problems,Varela thought of the neurophenomenology. The aim of this research is to study conscious experience based on the integration of neuroscience and phenomenology,the firstperson methods and the third-person methods.The propositions of neurophenomenology are as follows.Firstly,Subjectivity determines that the study of consciousness must integrate first-person and third-person methods,so as to enable the relationship between subjective and objective data to become a reciprocal constraint.Reciprocal constraints include three aspects:(1) the subjects are actively involved in generating and describing specific phenomenal invariants or phenomenal categories of their experience;(2) the neuroscientist is guided by these first-person data in the analysis and interpretation of neurobiological data,and a rigorous relationship between brain complexity and subjective experience is thereby established;(3) the neuroscientific analysis enriched by phenomenology can provoke revisions and rectifications of the phenomenological accounts,and enable the subjects to become aware of previously inaccessible aspects of their conscious experience.Secondly,in the perspective of neurophenomenology,conscious experiences are regarded as the products emerging from the activity of large-scale neural assemblies in the brain.This process is known as the large-scale integration problem.Furthermore,because large-scale integration occurs through some forms of temporal coding,the suitable-studied candidate for this kind of temporal coding is phase synchrony.Based on both aspects mentioned above,researchers carry out some neurophenomenological pilot studies.For instance,Lutz et al.(2002) investigated variations in conscious experience for one limited aspect of visual perception,specifically,under the condition of binocular disparities.The subjects experienced the emergence of an illusory 3D figure during the perceptual fusion of 2D random-dot images.In the experimental process,they simultaneously collected the first-person data and third-person data.The former were phenomenological reports,and the latter included the electrophysiological recordings and behavioural measures of button-pressing reaction time.The result shows that(1) the conscious experience of subjects fall into three main categories,Steady Readiness,Fragmented Readiness,and Unreadiness.(2) the subjective impression of discontinuity continuity is strongly correlated with a continuity/discontinuity in the brain dynamics.Although neurophenomenology proposes a clear scientific research program for making progress in integrating the brain and experience,it is still in its infancy. Further studies incorporating the latest third-person methods into first-person methods are essential,with the first-person data refined and the research scope expanded.

A review of the sufficient conditions for consciousness

Methodological aspects of studying the mechanisms of consciousness

Neural correlates of consciousness: progress and problems

The Science of Consciousness on Integrating Experience and the Brain——A Review on Varela's Neurophenomenology

Cortical synaptic basis of consciousness

Consciousness and brain function

[Some implications of the "consciousness and brain" problem]

Consciousness and neurosurgery

An evidence-based critical review of the mind-brain identity theory

Understanding Physical Processes in Describing a State of Consciousness: A Review

Imagination: The dawn of consciousness: Fighting some misconceptions in the discussion about consciousness

Consciousness, Decision-Making And Neural Computation

Chapter 9 Consciousness , Decision-Making and Neural Computation

The neural correlates of conscious experience: an experimental framework

The neurophysics of consciousness

An Adversarial Collaboration to Critically Evaluate Theories of Consciousness

Decoding the circuitry of consciousness: From local microcircuits to brain-scale networks

A Computational Neuroscience Approach to Consciousness

Simultaneity of consciousness with physical reality: the key that unlocks the mind-matter problem

The Finer Scale of Consciousness: Quantum Theory

Consciousness In Neural Networks?