Abstract:To quantitatively compare the aperture-based and beamlet-based inverse planning techniques and draw conclusion with regard to the dependence of plan quality on the number of segments of the incident fields using three clinical cases of different disease sites. We developed a combined aperture based inverse planning algorithm. After the number of segments was specified, the beam eyes views (BEVs) are applied to delineate the maximum MLC field boundary for each gantry angle. The BEV apertures were chosen to be the initial settings of aperture shapes and served as physical constraints of aperture settings. In the proposed algorithm, we utilized the fast adaptive simulated annealing (ASA) technique to select the field shapes defined by the MLC leaf coordinates. A descent gradient-based optimization technique was employed to search for the optimal aperture weights under the guidance of a conventional quadratic objective function. By combing the fast ASA with the descent gradient search algorithm, the computational efficiency was consistently improved. The beamlet-based inverse planning used the same objective function and the descent gradient-based optimization. Beamlet-based optimization with 1cm × 1cm size was used to obtain the optimized fluence maps (10 intensity levels). Three clinical cases (prostate, thoracic, and head and neck) were selected for the comparative study. For each case, the gantry angles are chosen manually and beamlet-based inverse planning was performed. Aperture based optimization was done with the same beam configuration and beam modality. A range of number of segments (5 to 25) was investigated. Plans with different number of segments were evaluated based on the DVH and dose distribution improvements and the treatment times involved. The combined aperture-based inverse planning algorithm was implemented and tested by comparing with conventional simulated annealing algorithm for aperture-based IMRT. The same quality plans were achieved but the computation time was reduced even by an order of magnitude. The improvement in performance directly was directly resulted from the fact that the objective function is well behaved analytical function with respect to beam weights. The key results found from the comparative study are that the dose distribution and DVHs were improved with the increase of the number of segments. When the number is increased up to ∼14, the dose distribution obtained from aperture based optimization is quite similar to that of the beamlet-based optimization provided the leaves can be adjusted in 0.2cm increments in the aperture-based inverse planning. Further increase of the segment number only lead to minor improvement in dose distributions with much increased computing time. Considering the tradeoff between the plan quality and planning time, it seems that the optimal number of segment is between 10 ∼ 20. Aperture-based inverse planning seems to be a viable option for IMRT and eliminating the step of leaf sequencing. For a few different disease sites, our study indicate that the technique can produce IMRT plans comparable with that of beamlet-based inverse planning when the number of segments per fields is above ∼10. The improvement saturates gradually as the number of segments increased to above ∼20.

Inverse versus convolution treatment planning algorithms for gamma knife radiosurgery

Clinical Evaluation of the Inverse Planning System Utilized in Gamma Knife Lightning

A preliminary study on a multi-resolution-level inverse planning algorithm for Gamma Knife radiosurgery

Is Real-Time Inverse Planning Optimizing Dose to the Normal Brain? A Prospective Comparative Trial in a Series of Brain Metastases Treated by Stereotactic Radiosurgery

A Preliminary Study on a Multi-Resolution-level Inverse Planning Approach for Gamma Knife Radiosurgery.

Quantitative Comparison of Aperture-Based and Beamlet-Based Inverse Planning Techniques

Impact of the skull contour definition on Leksell Gamma Knife® Icon™ radiosurgery treatment planning

Influence of Using a Contrast-Enhanced CT Image as the Primary Image on CyberKnife Brain Radiosurgery Treatment Plans

Dosimetric quality and delivery efficiency of robotic radiosurgery for brain metastases: Comparison with C-arm linear accelerator based plans.

Dosimetric comparison of glioblastoma radiotherapy treatment plans on a low-field MRI-guided linear accelerator compared to conventional C-arm linear accelerator

Dosimetric Comparisons of Different Hypofractionated Stereotactic Radiotherapy Techniques in Treating Intracranial Tumors > 3 Cm in Longest Diameter

Gamma knife radiosurgery clinical efficacy for brain stem glioma: The institutional experience

The Importance of the Conformality, Heterogeneity, and Gradient Indices in Evaluating Gamma Knife Radiosurgery Treatment Plans for Intracranial Meningiomas

Clinical application of deep learning-based synthetic CT from real MRI to improve dose planning accuracy in Gamma Knife radiosurgery: a proof of concept study

Synthetic CT for gamma knife radiosurgery dose calculation: A feasibility study

Dosimetry and efficiency comparison of knowledge-based and manual planning using volumetric modulated arc therapy for craniospinal irradiation

A plan quality control method of treatment planning for Gamma Knife radiosurgery

Treatment Planning Methods for Dose Painting by Numbers Treatment in Gamma Knife Radiosurgery

Comparison of different regines of inverse intensity modulated radiotherapy of post-operative patients with breast carcinoma

Dosimetric comparison of gamma knife and linear accelerator (VMAT and IMRT) plans of SBRT of Lung tumours

Noncoplanar VMAT for Brain Metastases: A Plan Quality and Delivery Efficiency Comparison with Coplanar VMAT, IMRT, and CyberKnife.