A study of dehydration by means of balance experiments

D. Black,R. Mccance,W. Young

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1944.sp004046

1944-04-04

Journal of Physiology

Abstract:A survey of the literature purporting to deal with the effects of water deprivation shows that most of it has really been concerned with the results of a deficiency of salt. In 1935, however, Kerpel-Fronius distinguished between the changes in the body due solely to a deficiency of salt, and those due simply to a shortage of water, but this important distinction has been little appreciated either in this country or in America, although Nadal, Pedersen & Maddock [1941] set out to contrast the features of these two syndromes in man. Unfortunately, in one of Nadal et al. two subjects the period of water deprivation followed directly upon one of salt deficiency, while in the other deprivation of water was accompanied by fasting. Hence, although results of great interest were obtained, the effects of water deprivation were complicated in one person by salt deficiency, and in the other by fasting. Admittedly, in clinical medicine, deprivation of water is usually accompanied by one or other of these complications, but warfare by sea or land may subject men with plenty of food to a shortage of water. The present paper describes the results of metabolism studies on two subjects, who abstained from water for 3 and 4 days respectively, during which they took a 'dry' diet adequate in protein, salt and calories. Although a balance experiment on a human being cannot be carried to the point where the biochemical cause of death becomes clearly stigmatized, it is possible to distinguish physico-chemical happenings in the early days of water deprivation which would, if they went on long enough, provide a reasonable modus moriendi. It is this chain of events which it is now proposed to describe.