The Optimization Design of a Lightweight 2 m SiC Mirror for Ground-Based Telescopes

Zhichen Wang,Tao Chen,Yuyan Cao,Wenqiang Fan,Honghao Wang,Wenpan Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/photonics11060581

IF: 2.536

2024-06-20

Photonics

Abstract:The weight of the primary mirror increases as the aperture of ground-based telescopes increases, making it more challenging to maintain the positional stability and surface accuracy of the solid primary mirror. Consequently, a 2 m lightweight silicon carbide (SiC) mirror and an optimization method were proposed in this study. The relationship between the gravitational deformation of the mirror and its thickness and number of supports was derived based on force analysis of the mirror; the thickness of the mirror and the appropriate number of supports were obtained as initial parameters for optimization. The back structure of the mirror was designed in a lotus pattern to improve its rigidity. Numerous structural parameters were classified into major and non-major parameters based on the results of a sensitivity analysis. The non-major and major structural parameters were optimized using a Latin hypercube design method and a non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm, respectively. The optimized 2 m lightweight SiC mirror had a mass of 119 kg and an areal density of 38.7 kg/m2. The surface figure error root-mean-square (RMS) in the vertical state of the optical axis and the first modal resonance of the mirror assembly calculated using finite element analysis were 11.3 nm and 76.5 Hz, respectively. Modal tests of the mirror assembly were conducted using the hammering method, achieving a maximum relative frequency error of 7.4% compared with the simulation results. The optimized 2 m SiC mirror was over 50% lighter than traditional passive Zerodur mirrors of the same size.

optics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: as the aperture of ground - based telescopes increases, the weight of the primary mirror also increases, which makes it more difficult to maintain the positional stability and surface accuracy of the primary mirror. Specifically, the paper aims to optimize the design of a lightweight 2 - meter silicon carbide (SiC) primary mirror to overcome the challenges encountered in the manufacturing, installation, and use of traditional heavy - duty primary mirrors.

### Specific manifestations of the problem:
1. **Weight increase**: As the aperture of the telescope increases, the weight of the primary mirror generally increases in proportion to the cube of the aperture, which places higher requirements on maintaining the positional stability and surface accuracy of the primary mirror.
2. **Structural complexity**: Heavy - duty primary mirrors not only increase the weight of the entire telescope but also affect the ability to track targets quickly and increase manufacturing costs.
3. **Limitations of existing technologies**: Although some studies have reduced the weight of the primary mirror through active support technologies and drilling, etc., these methods have problems such as complex structures and high costs.

### Goals of the solution:
1. **Weight reduction**: Significantly reduce the weight of the primary mirror through optimized design while maintaining its optical performance.
2. **Stiffness improvement**: Enhance the stiffness of the primary mirror and reduce gravitational deformation by selecting materials with high Young's modulus (such as SiC) and optimizing geometric dimensions.
3. **Optimization of the support structure**: Effectively reduce the gravitational deformation of the primary mirror by increasing the number of support points and reducing the distance between support points.

### Specific measures:
- **Theoretical analysis and formula derivation**: Based on force analysis, derive the relationship between the gravitational deformation of the primary mirror and its thickness and the number of support points, and determine the initial parameters.
- **Backplane structure design**: Design a lotus - like backplane structure to improve the stiffness of the primary mirror.
- **Parameter classification and optimization**: According to sensitivity analysis, divide the structural parameters into primary and non - primary parameters, and use the Latin hypercube design method and the non - dominated sorting genetic algorithm for optimization respectively.
- **Finite element analysis and experimental verification**: Calculate the surface error and resonance frequency of the primary mirror through finite element analysis, and conduct modal tests by the hammering method to verify the optimization results.

Finally, the optimized 2 - meter SiC primary mirror weighs 119 kg, with a surface density of 38.7 kg/m², a surface form and position error RMS of 11.3 nm, a first - mode resonance frequency of 76.5 Hz, and a maximum relative frequency error of 7.4%, reducing the weight by more than 50% compared to the traditional passive Zerodur primary mirror.