Admirable ends, ineffective means: comments on the alcohol harm reduction strategy for England

Thomas F Babor
2004-10-01
Abstract:Alcohol problems have plagued industrialized societies for centuries, and reports like The Alcohol Harm Reduction Strategy for England (Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit, 2004) are a common response to public concern that concerted government action is needed. Some reports are capable of translating scientific evidence into effective alcohol policy. Unfortunately, most reports in this genre are doomed to failure from the day they are published, either because the strategy proposed is ineffective, or a potentially effective strategy is incapable of implementation.How can we tell the difference between good and bad policy proposals? A place to start is by establishing a benchmark against the cumulative knowledge base on the subject of policy-relevant scientific research. During the past 25 years there has been remarkable growth in the amount and quality of empirical research on topics directly or indirectly related to …
What problem does this paper attempt to address?