Abstract:Background: High sensation-seekers (HSS) pursue novelty even at the cost of self-harm. When challenged, HSS are less anxious, show blunted physiological (cortisol, startle) and neurobiological (prefrontal-limbic) responses, and devalue aversive outcomes. Here, we investigate how these features interact under conditions of physical danger, in distinguishing between adaptive and maladaptive approaches to risk. Methods: We recruited a cohort of individuals who voluntarily sought out recreational exposure to physical risk, and obtained serial cortisol values over two time-locked days. On the 'baseline' day, we scanned subjects' brains with functional and structural MRI; on the 'skydiving day,' subjects completed a first-time tandem skydive. During neuroimaging, subjects viewed cues that predicted aversive noise; neural data were analyzed for prefrontal-limbic reactivity (activation) and regulation (non-linear complexity), as well as cortical thickness. To probe threat perception, subjects identified aggression for ambiguous faces morphed between neutral and angry poles. Results: Individuals with prefrontal-limbic meso-circuits with less balanced regulation between excitatory and inhibitory components showed both diminished cortisol/anxiety responses to their skydives, as well as less accurate perceptual recognition of threat. This impaired control was localized to the inferior frontal gyrus, with associated cortical thinning. Structural equation modeling suggests that sensation-seeking is primarily mediated via threat-perception, which itself is primarily mediated via neural reactivity and regulation. Conclusions: Our results refine the sensation-seeking construct to provide important distinctions (brain-based, but with endocrine and cognitive consequences) between the brave, who feel fear but nonetheless overcome it, and the reckless, who fail to recognize danger. This distinction has important real-world implications, as those who fail to recognize risk are less likely to mitigate it.

Estimating the perceived threat threshold for acting in self-defense

Perception of Threatening Intention Modulates Brain Processes to Body Actions: Evidence from Event-Related Potentials

Improved Perception of Aggression Under (un)Related Threat of Shock

Action opportunities modulate attention allocation under social threat.

Empirical test of a general process model of threat and defense: A systematic examination of the affective-motivational processes underlying proximal and distal reactions to threat

Eyes wide open: exploring men’s and women’s self-reported and physiological reactions to threat and crime

Does cost-benefit analysis or self-control predict involvement in two forms of aggression?

Threat in the Company of Men: Ensemble Perception and Threat Evaluations of Groups Varying in Sex Ratio

Conditions that increase the perceived likelihood of temporary restriction of firearm access: An investigation in male firearm owners

Threat as a Determinant of Alcohol-Related Aggression

Using risk of crime detection to study change in mechanisms of decision making.

Mitigating Risk? Set-Shifting Ability in High Threat Sensitive Individuals Predicts Approach Behavior During Simulated Peer-Rejection

Perceived Sanction Threats and Projective Risk Sensitivity: Auto Theft, Carjacking, and the Channeling Effect

The fine line between 'brave' and 'reckless': amygdala reactivity and regulation predict recognition of risk

Perceived probability, perceived severity, and health-protective behavior.

Independence Threat or Interdependence Threat? The Focusing Effect on Social or Physical Threat Modulates Brain Activity

Modeling Decision-Making in Schizophrenia: Associations Between Computationally Derived Risk Propensity and Self-Reported Risk Perception

Social threat learning transfers to decision making in humans

The effects of threat on complex decision-making: evidence from a virtual environment

Altered effective connectivity during threat anticipation in individuals with alcohol use disorder

Examining the reasons for student responses to threatening behaviors on a college campus.