Abstract:Panel data fail to support a subjective expected utility model of corporate deterrence. There is partial confirmation, however, that chief executives of small organizations who perceive the certainty of detection as high have better regulatory compliance in their organizations. Perceived sanction threats do not work significantly more effectively for chief executives (a) of for-profit versus nonprofit organizations; (b) who are owners as well as managers; (c) who say they think about sanctions more (sanction salience); and (d) who have a weaker belief in the law. Nor does the effectiveness of corporate deterrents depend on compliance costs. There is, however, a significant deterrent effect for managers who are low on emotionality, but an opposite counter-deterrent effect for actors high on emotionality. This supports the critique of those who condemn rational actor models from a sociology of the emotions perspective. Emotions of guilt among managers predict the subsequent compliance of their organizations. The results are consistent with perceptual deterrent studies of individuals that find little effect of formal sanctions and social disapproval as deterrents, but stronger support for an effect of self-disapproval (guilt or shame) on law observance. Qualitative data are used to show why it would be folly to interpret these results as showing that business regulation can work without sanction threats and social disapproval. Rather, the data evince the need for a complete reconceptionalization of the way policy analysts think about the deterrence of law breaking.

Perceived Sanction Threats and Projective Risk Sensitivity: Auto Theft, Carjacking, and the Channeling Effect

Do individual characteristics explain variation in sanction risk updating among serious juvenile offenders? Advancing the logic of differential deterrence.

Perceived Formal and Informal Sanctions in Deterring Cybercrime in a College Sample

A Meta-Analysis of Deterrence Theory in Information Security Policy Compliance Research

Neural Responses to Sanction Threats in Two-Party Economic Exchange

Effective sanction avoidance in drug trafficking: The construction and validation of the restrictive deterrence utility scale using a sample of female drug offenders

Victimization, Fear of Crime, and Perceived Risk: Testing a Vulnerability Model of Personal Control

Introducing Fear of Crime to Risk Research

Using risk of crime detection to study change in mechanisms of decision making.

Estimating the perceived threat threshold for acting in self-defense

THE THREAT OF VICTIMIZATION: A THEORETICAL RECONCEPTUALIZATION OF FEAR OF CRIME

Validating New Measures of the Fear of Crime

Burglary Victimization, Perceptions of Crime Risk, and Routine Activities: A Multilevel Analysis Across Seattle Neighborhoods and Census Tracts

The Dialectics of Corporate Deterrence

Classical deterrence theory revisited: An empirical analysis of Police Force Areas in England and Wales

Assessing the Relationships Between Past Victimization, Perceived Risk of Future Victimization, and Controversial Criminal Justice Policies Using Structural Equation Modeling

Deterring the Drunk Driver: An Examination of Conditional Deterrence and Self-Reported Drunk Driving

Conditions that increase the perceived likelihood of temporary restriction of firearm access: An investigation in male firearm owners

Street Youths and the Proximate and Contingent Causes of Instrumental Crime: Untangling Anomie Theory

Modelling the fear of crime

A psychological perspective on vulnerability in the fear of crime