Visualizing incommensurate inter-valley coherent states in rhombohedral trilayer graphene

Yiwen Liu,Ambikesh Gupta,Youngjoon Choi,Yaar Vituri,Hari Stoyanov,Jiewen Xiao,Yanzhen Wang,Haibiao Zhou,Barun Barick,Takashi Taniguchi,Kenji Watanabe,Binghai Yan,Erez Berg,Andrea F. Young,Haim Beidenkopf,Nurit Avraham

2024-11-18

Abstract:ABC-stacked rhombohedral graphene multilayers exhibit a wide variety of electronic ground states characterized by broken isospin symmetry and superconductivity. Recently, indirect evidence of inter-valley coherent (IVC) order has been reported in rhombohedral trilayer graphene (RTG), with possible implications for the origin of superconductivity. Here, we report the direct visualization of IVC order in RTG using scanning tunneling microscopy and spectroscopy. Tuning the chemical potential through the Van Hove singularity near the edge of the valence band, we observe a cascade of phase transitions associated with the formation of half- and quarter-metal states. IVC phases, distinguished by an enlarged real space unit cell, are directly imaged near both the high- and low-density boundaries of the half-metal phase. At high hole density, we precisely reconstruct the IVC band structure through quasiparticle interference. Intriguingly, the charge density modulations reveal a C3-symmetric incommensurate IVC order that agrees with the recent prediction of an IVC-crystal phase. Our findings demonstrate that IVC phases are a widespread symmetry-broken ground state within graphene systems.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to directly visualize and understand the existence and characteristics of the Inter - Valley Coherent (IVC) states in Rhombohedral Trilayer Graphene (RTG). Specifically, the researchers hope to observe the formation and evolution of IVC states at different chemical potentials through Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) and Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy (STS) techniques, especially at the high - density and low - density boundaries near the semimetallic phase. In addition, the paper also explores the possible connection between IVC states and superconducting phenomena, as well as the incommensurability characteristics of IVC states.

### Main contributions of the paper:
1. **Direct visualization of IVC states**: Through STM and STS techniques, the researchers directly observed IVC states in RTG for the first time, especially at different carrier densities near the semimetallic phase.
2. **Construction of detailed phase diagrams**: The researchers constructed phase diagrams of RTG under different carrier densities and displacement fields, revealing multiple phase - transition processes, including the transition from IVC states to semimetallic states and then to another IVC state.
3. **Discovery of incommensurate IVC crystalline states**: The study discovered a C3 - symmetric incommensurate IVC crystalline state, which has not been observed in other graphene systems, and its wave vector is consistent with theoretical predictions.
4. **Support from theoretical models**: Through Self - Consistent Hartree - Fock (SCHF) calculations, the researchers verified the band structure and scattering processes of the experimentally observed IVC states.

### Key results:
- **Direct imaging of IVC states**: In the high - hole - density and low - hole - density regions, the researchers observed the formation of IVC states, and these states have enlarged real - space unit cells.
- **Reconstruction of band structures**: Through Quasiparticle Interference (QPI) techniques, the researchers accurately reconstructed the band structure of IVC states and discovered multiple scattering branches.
- **Confirmation of incommensurability**: Through precise measurement of IVC Bragg peaks, the researchers confirmed the incommensurate nature of IVC states, and its wave vector exceeds the expected value of commensurate IVC states.

### Significance:
This research not only provides important experimental evidence for understanding the electron - correlation effects in RTG, but also lays the foundation for further exploring the relationship between IVC states and superconducting phenomena. In addition, the discovery of incommensurate IVC crystalline states opens up new directions for the study of phase diagrams and electronic states in graphene multilayer systems.