Intervalley coherence and intrinsic spin-orbit coupling in rhombohedral trilayer graphene

Trevor Arp,Owen Sheekey,Haoxin Zhou,C.L. Tschirhart,Caitlin L. Patterson,H. M. Yoo,Ludwig Holleis,Evgeny Redekop,Grigory Babikyan,Tian Xie,Jiewen Xiao,Yaar Vituri,Tobias Holder,Takashi Taniguchi,Kenji Watanabe,Martin E. Huber,Erez Berg,Andrea F. Young
2023-11-03
Abstract:Rhombohedral graphene multilayers provide a clean and highly reproducible platform to explore the emergence of superconductivity and magnetism in a strongly interacting electron system. Here, we use electronic compressibility and local magnetometry to explore the phase diagram of this material class in unprecedented detail. We focus on rhombohedral trilayer in the quarter metal regime, where the electronic ground state is characterized by the occupation of a single spin and valley isospin flavor. Our measurements reveal a subtle competition between valley imbalanced (VI) orbital ferromagnets and intervalley coherent (IVC) states in which electron wave functions in the two momentum space valleys develop a macroscopically coherent relative phase. Contrasting the in-plane spin susceptibility of the IVC and VI phases reveals the influence of graphene's intrinsic spin-orbit coupling, which drives the emergence of a distinct correlated phase with hybrid VI and IVC character. Spin-orbit also suppresses the in-plane magnetic susceptibility of the VI phase, which allows us to extract the spin-orbit coupling strength of $\lambda \approx 50\mu$eV for our hexagonal boron nitride-encapsulated graphene system. We discuss the implications of finite spin-orbit coupling on the spin-triplet superconductors observed in both rhombohedral and twisted graphene multilayers.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address issues primarily focused on understanding the intervalley coherence (IVC) state and the impact of intrinsic spin-orbit coupling in rhombohedral trilayer graphene. Specifically, the researchers explore the phase diagram of this material in the quarter-metal region through electronic compressibility and local magnetic measurements, with particular attention to the subtle competition between the valley imbalanced (VI) orbital ferromagnetic state and the intervalley coherent state. ### Main Issues: 1. **Competition between Intervalley Coherent State and Valley Imbalanced State**: - Researchers found that in rhombohedral trilayer graphene, there is competition between the valley imbalanced state (VI) and the intervalley coherent state (IVC). These two states are characterized by different relative phases of the electron wave function between the two valleys in momentum space. 2. **Impact of Spin-Orbit Coupling**: - The intrinsic spin-orbit coupling significantly affects the properties of these phases. By comparing the in-plane spin susceptibility of the IVC and VI phases, researchers revealed the role of spin-orbit coupling and extracted the spin-orbit coupling strength (λ ≈ 50 µeV). 3. **Understanding the Superconducting Mechanism**: - The paper also discusses the impact of finite spin-orbit coupling on the spin-triplet superconductors observed in rhombohedral and twisted multilayer graphene structures. This part aims to explore the role of spin-orbit coupling in the superconducting phase diagram. ### Solutions: - **Experimental Methods**: - Detailed exploration of the phase diagram of rhombohedral trilayer graphene using electronic compressibility and local magnetic measurement techniques. - Improved the accuracy of compressibility measurements through pyrolytic capacitors and additional low-temperature amplification stages. - **Theoretical Analysis**: - Calculated the phase diagram under different carrier densities and interlayer potential differences using the Hartree-Fock approximation. - Analyzed the impact of spin-orbit coupling on different phases, especially under low in-plane magnetic fields. ### Main Findings: - **Existence of Intervalley Coherent State**: - A significant intervalley coherent state (IVC) was found in the quarter-metal region, with a first-order phase transition between the IVC and VI states. - **Extraction of Spin-Orbit Coupling**: - Extracted the spin-orbit coupling strength (λ ≈ 46 µeV) by measuring the critical density changes under different magnetic fields. - **Discovery of Intermediate Phase**: - An intermediate phase between the IVC and VI phases was discovered under low in-plane magnetic fields, exhibiting partial valley imbalance characteristics, with a finite orbital magnetic moment but less suppressed in-plane susceptibility. ### Conclusion: This study, through detailed experimental and theoretical analysis, reveals the important roles of intervalley coherent state and spin-orbit coupling in rhombohedral trilayer graphene, providing new perspectives for understanding the superconducting mechanism in such materials.