Origin of Superconductivity in Rhombohedral Trilayer Graphene: Quasiparticle Pairing within the Inter-Valley Coherent Phase

Chun Wang Chau,Shuai A. Chen,K. T. Law
2024-04-30
Abstract:Superconductivity (SC) is observed in rhombohedral trilayer graphene (RTG) with an extremely low charge carrier densities, between the normal metal state and a probable inter-valley coherent (IVC) state. The measured coherence length in RTG is roughly two orders of magnitude shorter than the value predicted by a conventional BCS theory. To resolve these discrepancies, we propose that the RTG SC phase arises from the pairing of quasiparticles within the IVC phase. We illustrate the SC behavior using gapped Dirac cones with the chemical potential close to the conduction band's bottom and establish the Ginzburg-Landau theory. Our findings indicate that the mean-field transition temperature, $T_\mathrm{MF}$, is primarily determined by the density of states of quasiparticles within the IVC phase, and is more suppressed in comparison with the BCS relation. Interestingly, we discover that the coherence length behaves according to $\xi\sim 1/\sqrt{T_\mathrm{MF}}$. When the chemical potential lies within the band gap, the conventional coherence length becomes small, while the quantum metric contribution can diverge. Applying our approach to a microscopic model for RTG, our predictions align well with experimental data and effectively capture key measurable features of quantities such as the mean-field transition temperature $T_\mathrm{MF}$ and the coherence length $\xi$. Furthermore, we reveal that the quantum metric contribution, stemming from the multi-band properties of the IVC quasiparticles, plays a significant role in determining the coherence length around the transition regime from superconductivity to IVC. Lastly, experimental predictions are discussed on bebaviors of the upper critical field and coherence length at low temperatures.
Superconductivity,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the superconducting phenomenon (SC1) observed in rhombohedral trilayer graphene (RTG), especially the significant difference between this superconducting phenomenon and the predictions of the traditional BCS theory. Specifically, the paper points out: 1. **Inconsistency between experimental observations and theoretical predictions**: - The superconducting transition temperature (\( T_{\text{MF}} \)) and the upper critical field (\( H_{c2} \)) observed in the experiment are significantly different from the predictions of the traditional BCS theory. - The coherence length (\( \xi \)) measured in the experiment is two orders of magnitude smaller than the value predicted by the BCS theory. 2. **Re - interpretation of the superconducting mechanism**: - The paper proposes that the superconducting phenomenon in RTG is not caused by the pairing of free electrons in the normal metal state, but by the direct pairing of quasiparticles in the inter - valley coherent (IVC) state. - When the chemical potential approaches the top of the low - energy IVC quasiparticle band, the density of states of quasiparticles increases, which is favorable for the direct pairing to form s - wave superconductivity. 3. **Consistency between the theoretical model and experimental data**: - By constructing a simplified model (toy model), the paper analyzes the superconducting behavior when the chemical potential approaches the bottom of the band gap, and obtains the coherence length and transition temperature consistent with the experimental data. - Numerical calculations further verify this model, especially when considering the influence of the quantum metric, it can better explain the superconducting phase - transition characteristics observed in the experiment. ### Specific problem analysis #### 1. Inconsistency between experimental observations and BCS theory - **Transition temperature**: The highest transition temperature measured in the experiment is \( T_{\text{MF}} \approx 120 \text{mK} \), while according to the BCS theory, the expected transition temperature will be higher. - **Coherence length**: The coherence length measured in the experiment is \( \xi \approx 150 - 250 \text{nm} \), while according to the BCS theory, the expected coherence length is about \( 10^4 \text{nm} \). #### 2. Re - interpretation of the superconducting mechanism - **IVC state**: The paper proposes that the superconducting phenomenon SC1 is caused by the direct pairing of quasiparticles in the IVC state. The IVC state is a special electronic state in which the Fermi surfaces of the K and K' valleys are almost completely nested together, forming an energy gap. - **Effect of chemical potential**: When the chemical potential approaches the top of the low - energy IVC quasiparticle band, the density of states of quasiparticles increases, which is favorable for the formation of superconducting pairing. #### 3. Consistency between the theoretical model and experimental data - **Simplified model**: The paper constructs a simplified model for analyzing the superconducting behavior when the chemical potential approaches the bottom of the band gap. This model takes into account the density of states of quasiparticles and the pairing interaction. - **Numerical calculation**: Through numerical calculation, the paper verifies the predictions of the simplified model, especially when considering the influence of the quantum metric, it can better explain the superconducting phase - transition characteristics observed in the experiment. ### Conclusion By re - interpreting the mechanism of the superconducting phenomenon in RTG, the paper proposes that the direct pairing of quasiparticles in the IVC state is the cause of the superconducting phenomenon. This explanation not only solves the inconsistency between experimental observations and the traditional BCS theory, but also provides a more accurate theoretical framework for understanding the superconducting behavior in RTG.