Superfluid stiffness of twisted multilayer graphene superconductors

Abhishek Banerjee,Zeyu Hao,Mary Kreidel,Patrick Ledwith,Isabelle Phinney,Jeong Min Park,Andrew M. Zimmerman,Kenji Watanabe,Takashi Taniguchi,Robert M Westervelt,Pablo Jarillo-Herrero,Pavel A. Volkov,Ashvin Vishwanath,Kin Chung Fong,Philip Kim
2024-06-20
Abstract:The robustness of the macroscopic quantum nature of a superconductor can be characterized by the superfluid stiffness, $\rho_s$, a quantity that describes the energy required to vary the phase of the macroscopic quantum wave function. In unconventional superconductors, such as cuprates, the low-temperature behavior of $\rho_s$ drastically differs from that of conventional superconductors due to quasiparticle excitations from gapless points (nodes) in momentum space. Intensive research on the recently discovered magic-angle twisted graphene family has revealed, in addition to superconducting states, strongly correlated electronic states associated with spontaneously broken symmetries, inviting the study of $\rho_s$ to uncover the potentially unconventional nature of its superconductivity. Here we report the measurement of $\rho_s$ in magic-angle twisted trilayer graphene (TTG), revealing unconventional nodal-gap superconductivity. Utilizing radio-frequency reflectometry techniques to measure the kinetic inductive response of superconducting TTG coupled to a microwave resonator, we find a linear temperature dependence of $\rho_s$ at low temperatures and nonlinear Meissner effects in the current bias dependence, both indicating nodal structures in the superconducting order parameter. Furthermore, the doping dependence shows a linear correlation between the zero temperature $\rho_s$ and the superconducting transition temperature $T_c$, reminiscent of Uemura's relation in cuprates, suggesting phase-coherence-limited superconductivity. Our results provide strong evidence for nodal superconductivity in TTG and put strong constraints on the mechanisms of these graphene-based superconductors.
Superconductivity,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the superconducting properties in Magic-Angle Twisted Trilayer Graphene (MATMG), particularly the measurement of superfluid stiffness (\(\rho_s\)) and its significance in understanding unconventional superconductivity. ### Research Background and Objectives - **Basic Characteristics of Superconductors**: Superconductors exhibit macroscopic quantum phenomena such as zero resistance and the Meissner effect through the condensation of Cooper pairs. Superfluid stiffness \(\rho_s\) is a key physical quantity that describes the energy required for phase changes in the macroscopic wave function of a superconductor, distinguishing conventional from unconventional superconductors. - **Unconventional Superconductors**: For example, in cuprate superconductors with d-wave superconductivity, the superconducting gap has nodes in momentum space (gapless points), leading to significantly different behavior of \(\rho_s\) at low temperatures compared to conventional superconductors. - **Magic-Angle Twisted Multilayer Graphene (MATMG)**: A recently discovered material that exhibits strongly correlated electronic states and superconducting states, but its superconducting mechanism is not yet fully understood. ### Main Research Content - **Experimental Design and Methods**: The study uses RF reflection measurement techniques to probe the superfluid response of MATMG samples. The superfluid stiffness \(\rho_s\) is indirectly obtained by measuring the frequency changes of a microwave resonator. - **Measurement of Superfluid Stiffness**: Experiments conducted on Magic-Angle Twisted Trilayer Graphene (TTG) reveal unconventional nodal superconductivity. The results show that \(\rho_s\) has a linear dependence on temperature, indicating a nodal structure in the superconducting gap. - **Relationship Between Superconducting Transition Temperature \(T_c\) and \(\rho_s\)**: A linear relationship between \(\rho_s\) at zero temperature and \(T_c\) is found, similar to the Uemura relationship in cuprates, suggesting that the superconducting phase transition may be controlled by phase coherence rather than the strength of Cooper pairs. - **Multi-Parameter Dependence**: The study explores the variation of \(\rho_s\) with doping density and compares it with theoretical calculations, revealing the impact of non-parabolic band effects on superfluid stiffness. ### Conclusion - By measuring the superfluid stiffness of Magic-Angle Twisted Trilayer Graphene, the study provides strong evidence supporting the presence of nodal superconductivity in this system. - The discovered linear relationship suggests that the disruption of phase coherence in MATMG superconductivity may determine the superconducting transition temperature, rather than the strength of Cooper pairs. - The experimental results are significant for understanding the microscopic mechanisms of graphene-based superconductors.