Nematicity and Competing Orders in Superconducting Magic-Angle Graphene

Yuan Cao,Daniel Rodan-Legrain,Jeong Min Park,Fanqi Noah Yuan,Kenji Watanabe,Takashi Taniguchi,Rafael M. Fernandes,Liang Fu,Pablo Jarillo-Herrero

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abc2836

2020-04-09

Abstract:Strongly interacting electrons in solid-state systems often display tendency towards multiple broken symmetries in the ground state. The complex interplay between different order parameters can give rise to a rich phase diagram. Here, we report on the identification of intertwined phases with broken rotational symmetry in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (TBG). Using transverse resistance measurements, we find a strongly anisotropic phase located in a 'wedge' above the underdoped region of the superconducting dome. Upon crossing the superconducting dome, a reduction of the critical temperature is observed, similar to the behavior of certain cuprate superconductors. Furthermore, the superconducting state exhibits a anisotropic response to an directional-dependent in-plane magnetic field, revealing a nematic pairing state across the entire superconducting dome. These results indicate that nematic fluctuations might play an important role in the low-temperature phases of magic-angle TBG, and pave the way for using highly-tunable moiré superlattices to investigate intertwined phases in quantum materials.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to investigate the nematicity and other competing orders in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (TBG). Specifically, through experimental observation and analysis, the authors explore the following questions:

1. **Existence of Nematic Phase**: Is there a nematic phase in magic-angle TBG, i.e., a state where lattice rotational symmetry is spontaneously broken?
2. **Relationship Between Nematic and Superconducting Phases**: Are the nematic phase and superconducting phase intertwined, and how does this intertwining affect superconducting properties?
3. **Role of Nematic Fluctuations**: Do nematic fluctuations play a significant role in the phase transitions of magic-angle TBG at low temperatures?
4. **Impact of Many-Body Interactions**: How do strong electron-electron interactions lead to the competition and intertwining of various orders in magic-angle TBG?

### Main Findings

1. **Identification of Nematic Phase**: Through transverse resistance measurements, the authors found a strongly anisotropic phase above the underdoped region, exhibiting a "wedge-shaped" structure. This nematic phase appears at the top of the superconducting dome and gradually disappears as the temperature increases.
2. **Reduction of Superconducting Critical Temperature**: As the system crosses the superconducting dome, the critical temperature (Tc) significantly decreases, similar to the behavior of some copper-based superconductors.
3. **Anisotropic Response of the Superconducting State**: The superconducting state shows an anisotropic response to the in-plane magnetic field direction, revealing the presence of a nematic pairing state throughout the superconducting dome.
4. **Importance of Nematic Fluctuations**: These results suggest that nematic fluctuations may play an important role in the low-temperature phases of magic-angle TBG.

### Significance of the Research

This study not only reveals the complex many-body physics phenomena in magic-angle TBG but also provides new avenues for studying intertwined phases in quantum materials using highly tunable moiré superlattices. These findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the competition mechanisms between nematicity and other orders in strongly correlated electron systems, providing a theoretical foundation for the development of new superconducting materials.