Nematic superconductivity in twisted bilayer graphene

Dmitry V. Chichinadze,Laura Classen,Andrey V. Chubukov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.101.224513

2020-06-26

Abstract:Twisted bilayer graphene displays insulating and superconducting phases caused by exceptional flattening of its lowest energy bands. Superconductivity with highest $T_c$ appears at hole and electron dopings, near half-filling for valence or conduction bands. In the hole-doped case, the data show that three-fold lattice rotation symmetry is broken in the superconducting phase, i.e., a superconductor is also a nematic. We present the mechanism for nematic superconductivity. We take as an input the fact that at relevant dopings the Fermi energy lies in the vicinity of twist-induced Van Hove singularities in the density of states and argue that the low-energy physics can be properly described by patch models with six Van Hove points for electron doping and twelve Van Hove points for hole doping. We obtain pairing interactions for the patch models in terms of parameters of the microscopic model for the flat bands, which contains both local and twist-induced non-local interactions and show that the latter gives rise to attraction in different superconducting channels. For hole-doping, we find two attractive channels, $g$ and $i$-waves, with almost equal coupling constants. We show that in the co-existence state, where both order parameters are non-zero, the three-fold lattice rotation symmetry is broken, i.e., a superconductor is also a nematic. We find two possible nematic states, one is time-reversal symmetric, the other additionally breaks time-reversal symmetry. Our scenario for nematic superconductivity is based on generic symmetry considerations, and we expect it to be applicable also to other systems with two (or more) attractive channels with similar couplings.

Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the superconducting phenomena observed in Twisted Bilayer Graphene (TBG) and its related nematic phase transitions. Specifically, the authors focus on the following points:

1. **Symmetry breaking of the superconducting phase**: Experimental data show that in the hole-doped superconducting phase, the threefold lattice rotational symmetry (C3 symmetry) is broken, meaning the superconductor simultaneously exhibits a nematic phase. The authors attempt to explain the physical mechanism behind this phenomenon.

2. **Role of Van Hove singularities (VH)**: At the doping levels where superconductivity is observed, the Fermi level is near the Van Hove singularities induced by the twist. The authors analyze how these singularities affect low-energy physics and propose a pairing mechanism based on these singularities.

3. **Different pairing channels**: For electron doping and hole doping, the authors consider models with 6 and 12 Van Hove points, respectively. They find that for hole doping, there are two attractive pairing channels (g-wave and i-wave), while for electron doping, there is only one attractive d-wave channel.

4. **Formation of the nematic superconducting state**: By analyzing the free energy function, the authors demonstrate how the coexistence of two pairing channels can break the C3 rotational symmetry, leading to the formation of a nematic superconducting state. They also discuss two possible nematic states: one that preserves time-reversal symmetry and one that does not.

5. **Comparison of theory and experiment**: The authors' theoretical results are consistent with experimental observations, particularly in hole doping, where experiments have observed a twofold anisotropy in resistivity, which aligns with the theoretically predicted nematic phase.

In summary, this paper aims to explain the symmetry breaking phenomena of the superconducting phase in twisted bilayer graphene through detailed theoretical analysis, particularly the formation mechanism of the nematic superconducting state.