A response to commenter Ke Lan's comment on our paper published in Nature Communications (2023)14:5782 by J. Yan et al

Ji Yan,Jiwei Li,X. T. He,Lifeng Wang,Yaohua Chen,Feng Wang,Xiaoying Han,Kaiqiang Pan,Juxi Liang,Yulong Li,Zanyang Guan,Xiangming Liu,Xingsen Che,Zhongjing Chen,Xing Zhang,Yan Xu,Bin Li,Minging He,Hongbo Cai,Liang. Hao,Zhanjun Liu,Chunyang Zheng,Zhensheng Dai,Zhengfeng Fan,Bin Qiao,Fuquan Li,Shaoen Jiang,M. Y. Yu,Shaoping Zhu

2024-06-25

Abstract:A response to commenter Ke Lan's comment on our paper published in Nature Communications (2023)14:5782 by J. Yan et al

Plasma Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily responds to Ke Lan's comments on a previously published paper in "Nature Communications." The original paper is titled "Experimental verification of drive pressure enhancement and smoothing effects in hybrid-drive inertial fusion," authored by J. Yan et al. Ke Lan raised several points of contention in the comments, including:

1. **Pressure Asymmetry**: Ke Lan believes that the authors only mentioned the pressure asymmetry of Hybrid Drive (HD) and Indirect Drive (ID), but did not mention the pressure asymmetry of Direct Drive (DD).
2. **Role of DD Pressure**: Ke Lan pointed out that HD pressure did not explain the role of DD in pressure amplification.
3. **Relationship between HD Pressure and ID and DD Pressure**: Ke Lan argues that HD pressure should be superior to the sum of ID and DD pressure; otherwise, why not use DD or ID alone?
4. **Lack of Data**: Ke Lan believes that due to the lack of data from direct drive experiments under the same conditions, the paper's logic is flawed and the conclusions are unreliable.

In response to these concerns, the authors provided detailed explanations:

- **HD Pressure Does Not Include DD Pressure**: The authors emphasized that HD pressure does not contain any DD pressure components, so there is no need to conduct separate DD experiments to prove the characteristics of HD pressure.
- **Differences between HD and DD Schemes**: The authors explained in detail the differences between HD and DD schemes. In the HD scheme, radiation drive (ID) and laser direct drive (DD) act at different times; whereas in the DD scheme, the electron stripping rate is much lower than radiation, resulting in a shorter distance and inability to form a compression wave.
- **HD Pressure Generation Mechanism**: HD pressure achieves pressure enhancement and smoothing by increasing plasma density, and HD pressure is not a simple addition of ID and DD pressure.

In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to clarify Ke Lan's misunderstandings of their previous research conclusions and to explain in detail the generation mechanism of HD pressure and its differences from DD and ID pressure.