Switching between superconductivity and current density waves in Bernal bilayer graphene

Jun Ho Son,Yi-Ting Hsu,Eun-Ah Kim
2024-05-09
Abstract:An out-of-plane magnetic field can always suppress superconductivity. In Bernal-stacked bilayer graphene (BBG), recently observed activation of superconductivity (SC) through either in-plane magnetic fields or proximate spin-orbit coupling (SOC) offers a rare instance of switching superconductivity on. To understand this, we must first examine the non-superconducting state. We propose an incommensurate current density wave (CrDW) driven by van Hove singularities away from the zone corners as a competing order. We note that the two switches, the in-plane field and the SOC, both break spin degeneracy. Our parquet renormalization group analysis reveals that breaking spin degeneracy shifts the balance from CrDW, favored under spin degeneracy, to SC when degeneracy is lifted. Driven by purely repulsive interactions, the pairing symmetry of the resulting SC is $p/d$-wave. The presence of CrDW accounts for the non-linear $I-V$ behavior in the normal state and suggests potential anomalous Hall effects due to time-reversal symmetry breaking. We further predict that reducing screening could enhance SC.
Strongly Correlated Electrons,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the mechanism of how to activate superconductivity through in - plane magnetic fields or proximity spin - orbit coupling in Bernal - stacked bilayer graphene (BBG). Specifically, the paper explores how, in BBG, when there is an in - plane magnetic field or in contact with WSe₂, the transition from a non - superconducting state to a superconducting state occurs. This transition involves the switching between two competing order states: the superconducting state (SC) and the current - density - wave (CrDW). ### Core problems of the paper 1. **Superconductivity activation mechanism**: - How do in - plane magnetic fields or proximity spin - orbit coupling activate superconductivity in BBG? - How do these external conditions change the competing order states inside the system, thereby promoting the emergence of superconductivity? 2. **Properties of the non - superconducting state**: - In the absence of in - plane magnetic fields or proximity spin - orbit coupling, BBG exhibits high resistance and non - linear I - V characteristics, indicating that there may be a competing order state. - The paper proposes a non - coplanar current - density - wave (CrDW) driven by van Hove singularities as a candidate for this competing order state. 3. **Theoretical analysis**: - Using the parquet renormalization group (RG) method, study the transition of the system from the CrDW state to the superconducting state under different conditions (such as in - plane magnetic fields or proximity spin - orbit coupling). - Explore how the breaking of spin degeneracy affects the competition between these two order states. ### Main findings - **CrDW state**: In spin - degenerate BBG, the CrDW state is a major competing order state, manifested as a non - coplanar modulated current - density - wave with spontaneously broken time - reversal symmetry. - **Superconducting state**: When the spin degeneracy is broken (through in - plane magnetic fields or proximity spin - orbit coupling), the system transitions from the CrDW state to the p/d - wave superconducting state. - **Theoretical mechanism**: The breaking of spin degeneracy changes the interaction strength in the particle - hole channel, making the superconducting state the dominant order state. ### Suggestions for experimental verification 1. **Scanning tunneling microscope (STM)**: Detect the charge - density - wave (CDW) caused by CrDW. 2. **Anomalous Hall effect**: Detect the breaking of time - reversal symmetry by measuring the anomalous Hall effect. 3. **Reduce shielding effect**: Enhance superconductivity by reducing the shielding effect, for example, by changing the strength of spin - degeneracy splitting. Through these experimental verifications, it can be further confirmed whether the theoretical model proposed in the paper is correct.