Inducing superconductivity in bilayer graphene by alleviation of the Stoner blockade

Gal Shavit,Yuval Oreg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.108.024510

2023-07-31

Abstract:External magnetic fields conventionally suppress superconductivity, both by orbital and paramagnetic effects. A recent experiment has shown that in a Bernal stacked bilayer graphene system, the opposite occurs -- a finite critical magnetic field is necessary to observe superconducting features occurring in the vicinity of a magnetic phase transition. We propose an extraordinary electronic-correlation-driven mechanism by which this anomalous superconductivity manifests. Specifically, the electrons tend to avoid band occupations near high density of states regions due to their mutual repulsion. Considering the nature of spontaneous symmetry breaking involved, we dub this avoidance Stoner blockade. We show how a magnetic field softens this blockade, allowing weak superconductivity to take place, consistent with experimental findings. Our principle prediction is that a small reduction of the Coulomb repulsion would result in sizable superconductivity gains, both in achieving higher critical temperatures and expanding the superconducting regime. Within the theory we present, magnetic field and spin-orbit coupling of the Ising type have a similar effect on the Bernal stacked bilayer graphene system, elucidating the emergence of superconductivity when the system is proximitized to a $\rm WSe_2$ substrate. We further demonstrate in this paper the sensitivity of superconductivity to disorder in the proposed scenario. We find that a disorder that does not violate Anderson's theorem may still induce a reduction of $T_c$ through its effect on the density of states, establishing the delicate nature of the Bernal bilayer graphene superconductor.

Superconductivity,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to induce superconductivity in a bilayer graphene system by alleviating the so - called "Stoner blockade". Normally, an external magnetic field suppresses superconductivity, but recent experiments have found that in a bilayer graphene system, a finite critical magnetic field is necessary to observe superconducting characteristics. This phenomenon occurs near the magnetic phase transition, which is contrary to the behavior of traditional superconductors.

### Background of the paper

1. **Influence of external magnetic fields on superconductivity**:
- Normally, external magnetic fields suppress superconductivity through orbital and spin effects. The orbital effect will lead to a decrease in the superconducting energy gap and transition temperature, introduce vortices, and increase resistance.
- Spin effects (such as the Zeeman effect) can also break electron pairs, thus eliminating superconductivity.

2. **New findings**:
- Recent experiments have found that in a bilayer graphene system, a critical magnetic field is necessary to observe superconducting characteristics. This is contrary to the behavior of traditional superconductors because usually magnetic fields suppress superconductivity.
- This phenomenon occurs near the magnetic phase transition, indicating that there may be a new mechanism.

### Research questions

The paper attempts to explain why a critical magnetic field is required to observe superconductivity in a bilayer graphene system. Specifically, the authors propose a mechanism driven by electron correlations, namely "Stoner blockade".

### Main content

1. **Stoner blockade**:
- In the absence of an external magnetic field, the electric displacement field will modify the band structure of bilayer graphene, making the Fermi level close to the van Hove singularity (vHS), which is a region of high density of states.
- Due to Coulomb interactions, electrons tend to avoid occupying the high - density - of - states region, resulting in spontaneous band reconstruction and the formation of "Stoner blockade".
- Stoner blockade makes it difficult for the system to enter the superconducting state because the high - density - of - states region is blocked.

2. **Role of magnetic fields**:
- Applying an external magnetic field parallel to the sample plane can weaken Stoner blockade, allowing the system to approach the high - density - of - states region.
- The magnetic field is coupled to the electron spin through the Zeeman effect, reducing the interaction energy of the system, thus allowing the emergence of weak superconductivity.

3. **Theoretical predictions**:
- The authors predict that slightly reducing the Coulomb repulsion (for example, by adjusting the shielding strength of the nearby metal gate) can significantly increase the superconducting critical temperature and expand the superconducting region.
- Magnetic fields and Ising - type spin - orbit coupling (ISOC) have similar effects on bilayer graphene systems, which explains the enhancement of superconductivity when the system approaches the WSe₂ substrate.

### Conclusion

The paper proposes a new mechanism that explains why a critical magnetic field is required to observe superconductivity in a bilayer graphene system. This mechanism involves strong interactions between electrons and the modulation of these interactions by magnetic fields, providing a theoretical basis for understanding this abnormal superconducting behavior.