Abstract:Low-frequency qubit control wires require non-trivial thermal anchoring and low-pass filtering. The resulting electron temperature serves as a quality benchmark for these signal lines. In this technical note, we make use of a primary electron thermometry technique, using a Coulomb blockade thermometer, to establish the electron temperature in the millikelvin regime. The experimental four-probe measurement setup, the data analysis, and the measurement limitations are discussed in detail. We verify the results by also using another electron thermometry technique, based on a superconductor-insulator-normal metal junction. Our comparison of signal lines with QDevil's QFilter to unfiltered signal lines demonstrates that the filter significantly reduces both the rms noise and electron temperature, which is measured to be 22 $\pm$ 1 mK.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to accurately measure the electron temperature in qubit control lines in a low - temperature environment. Specifically, the authors used two techniques, the metallic Coulomb - blocking thermometer (CBT) and the superconductor - insulator - normal - metal (SIN) junction, to determine the effective electron temperature of low - frequency qubit control lines in a low - temperature dilution refrigerator. The focus of the study was to evaluate the impact of QDevil's low - temperature filter (QFilter) on reducing electron temperature and noise.
### Main problems
1. **Accurate measurement of electron temperature**:
- In a low - temperature environment, determining the effective electron temperature of qubit control lines is a challenge. Due to low electron - phonon coupling, the electron temperature is difficult to measure directly and requires special thermometer techniques.
2. **Evaluation of filter effectiveness**:
- Evaluate the effectiveness of QDevil's low - temperature filter (QFilter) in reducing electron temperature and noise. Verify the performance of the filter by comparing signal lines with and without the filter.
### Research methods
- **Experimental setup**:
- Use the four - probe measurement method, combined with a lock - in amplifier and other precision instruments, to perform CBT and SIN thermometer measurements.
- **Data processing**:
- Extract the electron temperature by analyzing the differential conductance curve. Specific steps include extracting the maximum conductance \( G_T \) and the minimum conductance \( G_{\text{min}} \), calculating the relative depth \( \Delta G / G_T \), and the full - width at half - maximum \( V_{1/2} \).
- **Theoretical model**:
- Use a theoretical model (such as Equation 3) to calculate the electron temperature and compare it with experimental data to verify the accuracy of the model.
- Consider the Joule heating effect and further verify the applicability of the model through numerical simulation and Monte Carlo simulation.
### Key formulas
- **Relationship between full - width at half - maximum and electron temperature**:
\[
T_e=\frac{V_{1/2}}{5.439k_BN}\left(1 + 0.3921\frac{\Delta G}{G_T}\right)
\]
where \( V_{1/2} \) is the full - width at half - maximum, \( k_B \) is the Boltzmann constant, \( N \) is the number of metal islands, and \( \Delta G / G_T \) is the relative depth of conductance decrease.
- **Joule heating effect**:
\[
T_e(V)=\left(\frac{P}{\Sigma\Omega}+T_0^5\right)^{1/5}
\]
where \( T_e(V) \) is the effective electron temperature after applying a bias voltage, \( P \) is the dissipated power, \( \Sigma \) is a material - dependent parameter, \( \Omega \) is the total volume of the metal islands, and \( T_0 \) is the temperature at zero bias voltage.
### Conclusions
- By using QDevil's QFilter, the electron temperature can be significantly reduced and noise can be reduced, making the electron temperature drop to 22 ± 1 mK.
- The study also found that at temperatures below 50 mK, the main temperature reading method has a systematic error, which is attributed to the Joule heating effect.
- By comparing with SIN thermometer data and verifying the theoretical model, the effectiveness and reliability of the CBT method at low temperatures were confirmed.
In summary, through detailed experimental and theoretical analysis, this paper successfully solved the problem of accurately measuring the electron temperature in qubit control lines in a low - temperature environment and evaluated the effectiveness of the low - temperature filter.