Measuring qubits with thermometers

David Pahl,William D. Oliver

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41928-024-01153-9

IF: 33.255

2024-04-26

Nature Electronics

Abstract:Nature Electronics, Published online: 25 April 2024; doi:10.1038/s41928-024-01153-9 A new approach to measuring qubits offers an alternative path to scaling quantum computers.

engineering, electrical & electronic

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Sequential-measurement thermometry with quantum many-body probes

Yaoling Yang,Victor Montenegro,Abolfazl Bayat

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevapplied.22.024069

IF: 4.6

2024-08-29

Physical Review Applied

Abstract:Measuring the temperature of a quantum system is an essential task in almost all aspects of quantum technologies. Theoretically, an optimal strategy for thermometry often requires measuring energy, which demands full accessibility over the entire system as well as a complex entangled measurement basis. In this paper, we take a different approach and show that single-qubit sequential measurements in the computational basis not only allow for precise thermometry of a many-body system, but may also achieve precision beyond the thermometry capacity of the probe at equilibrium, given by the Cramér-Rao bound. Thus, using consecutive single-qubit measurements of the probe out of equilibrium is, in most cases, very beneficial, as it achieves lower-temperature uncertainties and avoids demanding energy measurements when compared with probes at thermal equilibrium. To obtain such precision, the time between the two subsequent measurements should be smaller than the thermalization time so that the probe never thermalizes. Therefore, the nonequilibrium dynamics of the system continuously imprint information about temperature in the state of the probe. To demonstrate the generality of our findings, we consider thermometry in both spin chains and the Jaynes-Cummings model. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevApplied.22.024069 © 2024 American Physical Society

physics, applied
Non-Markovian enhancement of nonequilibrium quantum thermometry

Y. Aiache,C. Seida,K. El Anouz,A. El Allati

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physreve.110.024132

IF: 2.707

2024-08-26

Physical Review E

Abstract:Accurate measurement at low temperatures is essential for both gaining a fundamental understanding of physical processes and developing technological applications. In this paper, we propose a theoretical framework for quantum temperature sensing in a composite environment with non-Markovian dynamics. Our suggested system uses a single qubit as a temperature sensor to test its sensitivity in calculating the temperature of a composite environment. We show that the temperature sensor's sensitivity can saturate the quantum Cramér-Rao bound by measuring the σ̂z observable of the probe qubit. Temperature sensing performance is measured using the quantum signal-to-noise ratio. We underline how non-Markovianity can enhance the performance of our thermometers. Furthermore, we emphasize that nonequilibrium conditions do not always result in the best sensitivities in temperature estimation. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.110.024132 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Published by the American Physical Society

physics, fluids & plasmas, mathematical
Thermometry Based on a Superconducting Qubit

Dmitrii S. Lvov,Sergei A. Lemziakov,Elias Ankerhold,Joonas T. Peltonen,Jukka P. Pekola

2024-09-12

Abstract:We report temperature measurements using a transmon qubit by detecting the population of the first three levels of it, after employing a sequence of $\pi$-pulses and performing projective dispersive readout. We measure the effective temperature of the qubit and characterize its relaxation and coherence times $\tau_{1,2}$ for three devices in the temperature range 20-300 mK. Signal-to-noise (SNR) ratio of the temperature measurement depends strongly on $\tau_{1}$, which drops at higher temperatures due to quasiparticle excitations, adversely affecting the measurements and setting an upper bound of the dynamic temperature range of the thermometer. The measurement relies on coherent dynamics of the qubit during the $\pi$-pulses. The effective qubit temperature follows closely that of the cryostat in the range 100-250 mK. We present a numerical model of the qubit population distribution and compare it favorably with the experimental results.

Quantum Physics
Sequential measurements thermometry with quantum many-body probes

Yaoling Yang,Victor Montenegro,Abolfazl Bayat

2024-03-15

Abstract:Measuring the temperature of a quantum system is an essential task in almost all aspects of quantum technologies. Theoretically, an optimal strategy for thermometry requires measuring energy which demands full accessibility over the entire system as well as complex entangled measurement basis. In this paper, we take a different approach and show that single qubit sequential measurements in the computational basis not only allows precise thermometry of a many-body system but may also achieve precision beyond the theoretical bound, avoiding demanding energy measurements at equilibrium. To obtain such precision, the time between the two subsequent measurements should be smaller than the thermalization time so that the probe never thermalizes. Therefore, the non-equilibrium dynamics of the system continuously imprint information about temperature in the state of the probe. This allows the sequential measurement scheme to reach precision beyond the accuracy achievable by complex energy measurements on equilibrium probes.

Quantum Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons
Measuring two temperatures using a single thermometer

Harshit Verma,Fabio Costa

2024-06-05

Abstract:We consider the question: Is it possible to measure two temperatures simultaneously using a single thermometer? Under common circumstances, where the thermometer can interact with only one bath at a time and the interaction leads to complete thermalization, this is clearly impossible because the final state of the thermometer would be independent of the temperature of the first bath. In this work, we show that this task can indeed be accomplished with the assistance of quantum control. In particular, we consider a composite particle with multiple quantum degrees of freedom (DoF) as a temperature sensor, where one of the DoF -- termed as internal DoF -- is susceptible to the local temperature, thereby functioning as a thermometer, whereas another DoF -- termed external DoF -- is quantum-controlled. We leverage the entanglement between the aforementioned DoF in a composite particle for two-temperature thermometry by preparing the external DoF in a quantum superposition, exposing the internal DoF to two local temperatures. We show that such a particle used in a Mach-Zehnder type interferometer, or a quantum switch -- which allows quantum control over the order of application of quantum channels -- can be used to estimate two temperatures simultaneously, thus affirming our main proposition. For each of these setups, we obtain the variance in the estimated temperatures through the multi-parameter Cramér-Rao bound, and compare their performances based on the range of total variance of the two temperatures estimated. On benchmarking all the setups based on the total variance of the estimated temperatures, we find that a quantum switch with a qudit probe outperforms other setups. On restricting our probe to be a qubit, we find that quantum switch performs equally well as a Mach-Zehnder type interferometer.

Quantum Physics
Enhancing precision thermometry with nonlinear qubits

Sebastian Deffner

2024-08-30

Abstract:Quantum thermometry refers to the study of measuring ultra-low temperatures in quantum systems. The precision of such a quantum thermometer is limited by the degree to which temperature can be estimated by quantum measurements. More precisely, the maximal precision is given by the inverse of the quantum Fisher information. In the present analysis, we show that quantum thermometers that are described by nonlinear Schrödinger equations allow for a significantly enhanced precision, that means larger quantum Fisher information. This is demonstrated for a variety of pedagogical scenarios consisting of single and two-qubits systems. The enhancement in precision is indicated by non-vanishing quantum speed limits, which originate in the fact that the thermal, Gibbs state is typically not invariant under the nonlinear equations of motion.

Statistical Mechanics,Quantum Physics
Simulating and Optimising Quantum Thermometry Using Single Photons

W. K. Tham,H. Ferretti,A. V. Sadashivan,A. M. Steinberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/srep38822

IF: 4.6

2016-12-01

Scientific Reports

Abstract:A classical thermometer typically works by exchanging energy with the system being measured until it comes to equilibrium, at which point the readout is related to the final energy state of the thermometer. A recent paper noted that with a quantum thermometer consisting of a single spin/qubit, temperature discrimination is better achieved at finite times rather than once equilibration is essentially complete. Furthermore, preparing a qubit thermometer in a state with quantum coherence instead of an incoherent one improves its sensitivity to temperature differences. Implementing a recent proposal for efficiently emulating an arbitrary quantum channel, we use the quantum polarisation state of individual photons as models of “single-qubit thermometers” which evolve for a certain time in contact with a thermal bath. We investigate the optimal thermometer states for temperature discrimination, and the optimal interaction times, confirming that there is a broad regime where quantum coherence provides a significant improvement. We also discuss the more practical question of thermometers composed of a finite number of spins/qubits (greater than one), and characterize the performance of an adaptive protocol for making optimal use of all the qubits.

multidisciplinary sciences
Non-Markovian Quantum Thermometry

Ning Zhang,Chong Chen,Si-Yuan Bai,Wei Wu,Jun-Hong An

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevapplied.17.034073

IF: 4.6

2022-03-30

Physical Review Applied

Abstract:The rapidly developing quantum technologies and thermodynamics have put forward a requirement to precisely control and measure the temperature of microscopic matter at the quantum level. Many quantum thermometry schemes have been proposed. However, precisely measuring low temperature is still challenging because the obtained sensing errors generally tend to diverge with decreasing temperature. Using a continuous-variable system as a thermometer, we propose non-Markovian quantum thermometry to measure the temperature of a quantum reservoir. A mechanism to make the sensing error δT scale with the temperature T as the Landau bound δT≃T in the full-temperature regime is discovered. Our analysis reveals that it is the quantum criticality of the total thermometer-reservoir system that causes this enhanced sensitivity. Efficiently avoiding the error-divergence problem, our result gives an efficient way to precisely measure the low temperature of quantum systems.

physics, applied
Real-time milli-Kelvin thermometry in a semiconductor qubit architecture

Victor Champain,Vivien Schmitt,Benoit Bertrand,Heimanu Niebojewski,Romain Maurand,Xavier Jehl,Clemens Winkelmann,Silvano De Franceschi,Boris Brun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevApplied.21.064039

2024-06-20

Abstract:We report local time-resolved thermometry in a silicon nanowire quantum dot device designed to host a linear array of spin qubits. Using two alternative measurement schemes based on rf reflectometry, we are able to probe either local electron or phonon temperatures with $\mu$s-scale time resolution and a noise equivalent temperature of $3$ $\rm mK/\sqrt{\rm Hz}$. Following the application of short microwave pulses, causing local periodic heating, time-dependent thermometry can track the dynamics of thermal excitation and relaxation, revealing clearly different characteristic time scales. This work opens important prospects to investigate the out-of-equilibrium thermal properties of semiconductor quantum electronic devices operating at very low temperature. In particular, it may provide a powerful handle to understand heating effects recently observed in semiconductor spin-qubit systems.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
Low-temperature quantum thermometry boosted by coherence generation

Asghar Ullah,M. Tahir Naseem,Özgür E. Müstecaplıoğlu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.5.043184

2023-11-20

Abstract:The precise measurement of low temperatures is significant for both the fundamental understanding of physical processes and technological applications. In this work, we present a method for low-temperature measurement that improves thermal range and sensitivity by generating quantum coherence in a thermometer probe. Typically, in temperature measurements, the probes thermalize with the sample being measured. However, we use a two-level quantum system, or qubit, as our probe and prevent direct probe access to the sample by introducing a set of ancilla qubits as an interface. We describe the open system dynamics of the probe using a global master equation and demonstrate that while the ancilla-probe system thermalizes with the sample, the probe \textit{per se} evolves into a nonthermal steady state due to nonlocal dissipation channels. The populations and coherences of this steady state depend on the sample temperature, allowing for precise and wide-range low-temperature estimation. We characterize the thermometric performance of the method using quantum Fisher information and show that the quantum Fisher information can exhibit multiple and higher peaks at different low temperatures with increasing quantum coherence and the number of ancilla qubits. Our analysis reveals that the proposed approach, using a nonthermal qubit thermometer probe with temperature-dependent quantum coherence generated by a multiple qubit interface between a thermal sample and the probe qubit, can enhance the sensitivity of temperature estimation and broaden the measurable low-temperature range.

Quantum Physics
Fast, Accurate, and Local Temperature Control Using Qubits

Riya Baruah,Pedro Portugal,Joachim Wabnig,Christian Flindt

2024-10-07

Abstract:Many quantum technologies, including quantum computers, quantum heat engines, and quantum sensors, rely on operating conditions in the subkelvin regime. It is therefore desirable to develop practical tools and methods for the precise control of the temperature in nanoscale quantum systems. Here, we present a proposal for fast, accurate, and local temperature control using qubits, which regulate the flow of heat between a quantum system and its thermal environment. The qubits are kept in a thermal state with a temperature that is controlled in an interplay between work done on the qubits by changing their energy splittings and the flow of heat between the qubits and the environment. Using only a few qubits, it is possible to control the thermal environment of another quantum system, which can be heated or cooled by the qubits. As an example, we show how a quantum system at subkelvin temperatures can be significantly and accurately cooled on a nanosecond timescale. Our proposal can potentially be realized with superconducting flux qubits, charge qubits, or spin qubits, which can now be fabricated and manipulated with exquisite control.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Quantum Physics
Measuring the heat exchange of a quantum process

John Goold,Ulrich Poschinger,Kavan Modi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.90.020101

2014-08-19

Abstract:Very recently, interferometric methods have been proposed to measure the full statistics of work performed on a driven quantum system [Dorner et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 230601 (2013)] and [Mazzola et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 230602 (2013)]. The advantage of such schemes is that they replace the necessity to make projective measurements by performing phase estimation on an appropriately coupled ancilla qubit. These proposals are one possible route to the tangible experimental exploration of quantum thermodynamics, a subject which is the centre of much current attention due to the current control of mesoscopic quantum systems. In this Letter we demonstrate that a modification of the phase estimation protocols can be used in order to measure the heat distribution of a quantum process. In addition we demonstrate how our scheme may be implemented using ion trap technology. Our scheme should pave the way for the first experimental explorations of the Landauer principle and hence the intricate energy to information conversion in mesoscopic quantum systems.

Quantum Physics,Statistical Mechanics
Primary thermometry triad at 6 mK in mesoscopic circuits

Z. Iftikhar,A. Anthore,S. Jezouin,F.D. Parmentier,Y. Jin,A. Cavanna,A. Ouerghi,U. Gennser,F. Pierre

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms12908

2016-10-12

Abstract:Quantum physics emerge and develop as temperature is reduced. Although mesoscopic electrical circuits constitute an outstanding platform to explore quantum behavior, the challenge in cooling the electrons impedes their potential. The strong coupling of such micrometer-scale devices with the measurement lines, combined with the weak coupling to the substrate, makes them extremely difficult to thermalize below 10 mK and imposes in-situ thermometers. Here we demonstrate electronic quantum transport at 6 mK in micrometer-scale mesoscopic circuits. The thermometry methods are established by the comparison of three in-situ primary thermometers, each involving a different underlying physics. The employed combination of quantum shot noise, quantum back-action of a resistive circuit and conductance oscillations of a single-electron transistor covers a remarkably broad spectrum of mesoscopic phenomena. The experiment, performed in vacuum using a standard cryogen-free dilution refrigerator, paves the way toward the sub-millikelvin range with additional thermalization and refrigeration techniques.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Instrumentation and Detectors,Quantum Physics
Topological quantum thermometry

Anubhav Kumar Srivastava,Utso Bhattacharya,Maciej Lewenstein,Marcin Płodzień

2023-11-24

Abstract:An optimal local quantum thermometer is a quantum many-body system that saturates the fundamental lower bound for the thermal state temperature estimation accuracy [L. Correa, et. al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 220405 (2015)]. Such a thermometer has a particular energy level structure with a single ground state and highly degenerated excited states manifold, with an energy gap proportional to the estimated temperature. In this work, we show that the optimal local quantum thermometer can be realized in an experimentally feasible system of spinless fermions confined in a one-dimensional optical lattice described by the Rice-Mele model. We characterize the system's sensitivity to temperature changes in terms of quantum Fisher information and the classical Fisher information obtained from experimentally available site occupation measurements.

Quantum Physics,Quantum Gases,Atomic Physics
Measurement-Based Quantum Thermal Machines with Feedback Control

Bibek Bhandari,Robert Czupryniak,Paolo Andrea Erdman,Andrew N. Jordan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/e25020204

IF: 2.738

2023-01-20

Entropy

Abstract:We investigated coupled-qubit-based thermal machines powered by quantum measurements and feedback. We considered two different versions of the machine: (1) a quantum Maxwell's demon, where the coupled-qubit system is connected to a detachable single shared bath, and (2) a measurement-assisted refrigerator, where the coupled-qubit system is in contact with a hot and cold bath. In the quantum Maxwell's demon case, we discuss both discrete and continuous measurements. We found that the power output from a single qubit-based device can be improved by coupling it to the second qubit. We further found that the simultaneous measurement of both qubits can produce higher net heat extraction compared to two setups operated in parallel where only single-qubit measurements are performed. In the refrigerator case, we used continuous measurement and unitary operations to power the coupled-qubit-based refrigerator. We found that the cooling power of a refrigerator operated with swap operations can be enhanced by performing suitable measurements.

physics, multidisciplinary
Achieving Heisenberg scaling in low-temperature quantum thermometry

Ning Zhang,Chong Chen

2024-07-08

Abstract:We investigate correlation-enhanced low temperature quantum thermometry. Recent studies have revealed that bath-induced correlations can enhance the low-temperature estimation precision even starting from an uncorrelated state. However, a comprehensive understanding of this enhancement remains elusive. Using the Ramsey interferometry protocol, we illustrate that the estimation precision of $N$ thermometers sparsely coupled to a common low-temperature bath can achieve the Heisenberg scaling in the low-temperature regime with only a $\pi/2$ rotation of the measurement axis, in contrast to the standard Ramsey scheme. This result is based on the assumption that interthermometer correlations are induced exclusively by low-frequency noise in the common bath, a condition achievable in practical experimental scenarios. The underlying physical mechanism is clarified, revealing that the Heisenberg scaling arises from the intrinsic nature of the temperature, which is associated solely with the fluctuation of thermal noise. In contrast to the paradigm of independent thermometers, our proposed scheme demonstrates a significant enhancement in precision for low-temperature measurement, making it suitable for precisely measuring the temperature of ultracold systems.

Quantum Physics
Measurement-Induced Transmon Ionization

Marie Frédérique Dumas,Benjamin Groleau-Paré,Alexander McDonald,Manuel H. Muñoz-Arias,Cristóbal Lledó,Benjamin D’Anjou,Alexandre Blais

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevx.14.041023

2024-10-25

Physical Review X

Abstract:Theoretical work provides a long-awaited explanation for why measurements of qubits in superconducting quantum computers are less accurate than expected. [Phys. Rev. X 14, 041023] Published Thu Oct 24, 2024

physics, multidisciplinary
Coherence-enhanced single-qubit thermometry out of equilibrium

Gonçalo Frazao,Marco Pezzutto,Yasser Omar,Emmanuel Zambrini Cruzeiro,Stefano Gherardini

2024-05-23

Abstract:The metrological limits of thermometry operated in nonequilibrium dynamical regimes are analyzed. We consider a finite-dimensional quantum system, employed as a quantum thermometer, in contact with a thermal bath inducing Markovian thermalization dynamics. The quantum thermometer is initialized in a generic quantum state, possibly including quantum coherence w.r.t. the Hamiltonian basis. We prove that the sensitivity of the thermometer, quantified by the quantum Fisher information, is enhanced by the quantum coherence in its initial state. We analytically show this in the specific case of qubit thermometers for which the maximization of the quantum Fisher information occurs at a finite time during the transient of the thermalization dynamics. Such a finite-time sensitivity enhancement can be better than the sensitivity that is achieved asymptotically.

Quantum Physics
Bayesian quantum thermometry based on thermodynamic length

Mathias R. Jørgensen,Jan Kołodyński,Mohammad Mehboudi,Martí Perarnau-Llobet,Jonatan B. Brask

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.105.042601

2022-04-03

Abstract:In this work we propose a theory of temperature estimation of quantum systems, which is applicable in the regime of non-negligible prior temperature uncertainty and limited measurement data. In this regime the problem of establishing a well-defined measure of estimation precision becomes nontrivial. Furthermore, the construction of a suitable criterion for optimal measurement design must be reexamined to account for the prior uncertainty. We propose a fully Bayesian approach to temperature estimation based on the concept of thermodynamic length, which solves both these problems. As an illustration of this framework, we consider thermal spin- 1/2 particles and investigate the fundamental difference between two cases: on the one hand, when the spins are probing the temperature of a heat reservoir and, on the other, when the spins themselves constitute the sample. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.105.042601 ©2022 American Physical Society
Low-temperature benchmarking of qubit control wires by primary electron thermometry

Elias Roos Hansen,Ferdinand Kuemmeth,Joost van der Heijden

2024-03-26

Abstract:Low-frequency qubit control wires require non-trivial thermal anchoring and low-pass filtering. The resulting electron temperature serves as a quality benchmark for these signal lines. In this technical note, we make use of a primary electron thermometry technique, using a Coulomb blockade thermometer, to establish the electron temperature in the millikelvin regime. The experimental four-probe measurement setup, the data analysis, and the measurement limitations are discussed in detail. We verify the results by also using another electron thermometry technique, based on a superconductor-insulator-normal metal junction. Our comparison of signal lines with QDevil's QFilter to unfiltered signal lines demonstrates that the filter significantly reduces both the rms noise and electron temperature, which is measured to be 22 $\pm$ 1 mK.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Quantum Physics

Measuring qubits with thermometers

Sequential-measurement thermometry with quantum many-body probes

Non-Markovian enhancement of nonequilibrium quantum thermometry

Thermometry Based on a Superconducting Qubit

Sequential measurements thermometry with quantum many-body probes

Measuring two temperatures using a single thermometer

Enhancing precision thermometry with nonlinear qubits

Simulating and Optimising Quantum Thermometry Using Single Photons

Non-Markovian Quantum Thermometry

Real-time milli-Kelvin thermometry in a semiconductor qubit architecture

Low-temperature quantum thermometry boosted by coherence generation

Fast, Accurate, and Local Temperature Control Using Qubits

Measuring the heat exchange of a quantum process

Primary thermometry triad at 6 mK in mesoscopic circuits

Topological quantum thermometry

Measurement-Based Quantum Thermal Machines with Feedback Control

Achieving Heisenberg scaling in low-temperature quantum thermometry

Measurement-Induced Transmon Ionization

Coherence-enhanced single-qubit thermometry out of equilibrium

Bayesian quantum thermometry based on thermodynamic length

Low-temperature benchmarking of qubit control wires by primary electron thermometry