Abstract:In the 17th and 18th centuries, several natural philosophers studied the phenomenon of refraction and attempted to obtain the Snell law from various assumptions. Lacking experimental data, it was generally believed that light travels faster in a refracting medium than in air. In the present article, I review the contributions to the problem of light refraction by Descartes, Fermat, Huygens, Leibniz, Newton, Clairaut, and finally Maupertuis who established a principle of least action based on his own approach to the problem.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the refraction phenomenon of light and the physical principles behind it. In the 17th and 18th centuries, many natural philosophers studied the refraction phenomenon of light and tried to derive Snell's Law, that is, the angular relationship between the incident ray and the refracted ray, from different hypotheses. Due to the lack of experimental data at that time, it was generally believed that the speed of light propagation in the refracting medium was faster than that in the air. This paper reviews the contributions of Descartes, Fermat, Huygens, Leibniz, Newton, Clairaut and Maupertuis to the problem of light refraction, especially Maupertuis' research on this problem based on the principle of least action.
Specifically, the paper explores the following points:
1. **Descartes**: He believed that the speed of light propagation in the medium was faster and derived Snell's Law through geometric reasoning.
2. **Fermat**: He assumed that light propagated more slowly in the medium and derived Snell's Law through the principle of least time.
3. **Huygens**: He proposed the wave theory, assuming that light waves propagated more slowly in the medium, and thus derived Snell's Law.
4. **Leibniz**: Inspired by Fermat, he proposed the concept of "the easiest path" for light, but the final result was similar to Fermat's principle of least time.
5. **Newton**: He assumed that light was composed of particles and believed that there was some force in the medium to increase the speed of light, thus explaining the refraction phenomenon.
6. **Clairaut**: He supported Newton's view, but thought that this force only existed in the thin layer on the surface of the medium.
7. **Maupertuis**: He proposed the principle of least action, believing that light follows the path with the least action during the propagation process, and extended this principle to a wider range of physical phenomena.
In general, the paper aims to sort out the different views and methods of these scientists on the problem of light refraction and their contributions to the development of physics.