Refractive index for the mechanical refraction of a relativistic particle

Bikram Keshari Behera,Surendra Kumar Gour,Shyamal Biswas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjd/s10053-024-00849-z

2024-05-23

Abstract:We have analytically determined the refractive index for the mechanical refraction of a relativistic particle for its all possible speeds. We have critically analysed the importance of Descartes' metaphysical theory and extended it in this regard. We have considered the conservation of the tangential component of the relativistic momentum and the relativistic energy of the particle in the process of the mechanical refraction within the optical-mechanical analogy. Our result for the mechanical refractive index exactly matches with the forms of both the Fermat's result on Snell's law of optical refraction at the ultra-relativistic limit and the Descartes' metaphysical result on the pseudo-Snell law of optical refraction at the non-relativistic limit.

Classical Physics,History and Philosophy of Physics,Optics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine the refractive index of relativistic particles during mechanical refraction. Specifically, by analyzing the refraction phenomena of relativistic particles at different velocities, the authors extended Descartes' metaphysical theory and, in combination with the analogical relationship between optics and mechanics, considered the conservation of the tangential component of the relativistic momentum and the relativistic energy of particles during the refraction process. Their goal was to derive an expression for the mechanical refractive index applicable to all possible velocities and verify that this expression matches the forms of Descartes' pseudo - Snell's law and Fermat's Snell's law in the non - relativistic limit and the ultra - relativistic limit respectively.

### Main Contributions
1. **Theoretical Expansion**: The authors extended Descartes' metaphysical theory, taking into account relativistic effects, especially the conservation of the relativistic momentum and energy of particles during mechanical refraction.
2. **Refractive Index Expression**: Derived an expression for the mechanical refractive index applicable to all velocity ranges, which can be reduced to known classical results under different limit conditions.
3. **Optics - Mechanics Analogy**: Through the analogy between optics and mechanics, the authors used the Helmholtz wave equation and the Klein - Gordon equation to define and derive the mechanical refractive index.
4. **Verification and Application**: Verified that in the non - relativistic limit and the ultra - relativistic limit, the mechanical refractive index expression is consistent with the forms of Descartes' pseudo - Snell's law and Fermat's Snell's law respectively, providing a theoretical basis for future research.

### Formula Summary
- **General Expression for Mechanical Refractive Index**:
\[
n(\vec{r})=\frac{\sqrt{(E - V(\vec{r}))^{2}-m_{0}^{2}c^{4}}}{\sqrt{E^{2}-m_{0}^{2}c^{4}}}
\]
where \(E\) is the relativistic energy of the particle, \(V(\vec{r})\) is the potential energy, \(m_{0}\) is the rest mass of the particle, and \(c\) is the speed of light.

- **Mechanical Refractive Index in the Non - Relativistic Limit**:
\[
n(\vec{r})\approx\frac{1}{\sqrt{2m_{0}c^{2}(E_{\text{nr}}-V(\vec{r}))}}
\]
where \(E_{\text{nr}}=\frac{1}{2}m_{0}v^{2}+V(\vec{r})\) is the non - relativistic energy of the particle, and \(v\) is the velocity of the particle.

- **Mechanical Refractive Index in the Ultra - Relativistic Limit**:
\[
n(\vec{r})\to\frac{c}{v_{p}}
\]
where \(v_{p}\) is the phase velocity of the particle.

### Conclusion
Through the above research, the authors not only successfully derived an expression for the mechanical refractive index applicable to all velocity ranges but also verified the validity of this expression under different limit conditions. This result provides a new perspective for understanding the refraction phenomena of relativistic particles and lays a theoretical foundation for future research on the transmission and reflection of particles in engineering media.