Why history matters: ab initio rederivation of Fresnel equations confirms microscopic theory of refractive index

R. Starke,G. A. H. Schober

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijleo.2017.11.026

2017-12-16

Abstract:We provide a systematic theoretical, experimental, and historical critique of the standard derivation of Fresnel's equations, which shows in particular that these well-established equations actually contradict the traditional, macroscopic approach to electrodynamics in media. Subsequently, we give a rederivation of Fresnel's equations which is exclusively based on the microscopic Maxwell equations and hence in accordance with modern first-principles materials physics. In particular, as a main outcome of this analysis being of a more general interest, we propose the most general boundary conditions on electric and magnetic fields which are valid on the microscopic level.

Optics,Classical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: to prove that the Fresnel equations are also valid in the microscopic framework. Specifically, the paper aims to re - derive the Fresnel equations from first - principles through the microscopic Maxwell equations, thereby verifying that these equations are consistent with the microscopic theories in modern material physics.

### Background and Motivation
1. **Limitations of the Classical Approach**
- The classical Fresnel equations are usually derived within the framework of macroscopic electromagnetism, which is fundamentally different from the microscopic framework used in modern first - principles methods.
- Some assumptions in the macroscopic approach (such as relative magnetic permeability \(\mu_r = 1\)) may not hold at the microscopic level, which leads to contradictions between the classical derivation and experimental results.

2. **Importance of the First - Principles Method**
- The first - principles method is becoming increasingly important in material physics, especially in calculating dielectric functions, etc.
- The development of modern polarization theory further emphasizes the necessity of the microscopic framework.

### Main Objectives of the Paper
1. **Re - derivation of the Fresnel Equations**
- Re - derive the Fresnel equations using the microscopic Maxwell equations, ensuring that the derivation process is consistent with modern first - principles material physics.
- Propose the most general electromagnetic field boundary conditions that are valid at the microscopic level.

2. **Verify the Validity of the Microscopic Derivation**
- Prove that the re - derived Fresnel equations are consistent with experimental results, especially with the results of experimental techniques such as Brewster's angle, reflectivity, and ellipsometry.

### Specific Steps
1. **Review of the Standard Derivation**
- Review the derivation process of the classical Fresnel equations and point out the assumptions and limitations therein.
- Emphasize that in the standard derivation, it is necessary to assume \(\mu_r = 1\) in order to obtain the correct Fresnel equations, and this assumption may not hold in some cases.

2. **Historical Review**
- Outline the historical background of optical experiments and theoretical development, and explain the origin of the Fresnel equations and their verification processes in different historical periods.
- Emphasize the independence and reliability of the Fresnel equations. Even in the absence of modern electromagnetism theories, these equations have been widely verified.

3. **Introduction of the Functional Method**
- Introduce the functional method based on the microscopic Maxwell equations and explain how to handle electromagnetic field boundary conditions at the microscopic level.
- Derive the new Fresnel equations in detail and show their consistency with the classical equations.

### Conclusion
By re - deriving the Fresnel equations, the paper proves that these equations are still valid in the microscopic framework, thus providing a solid theoretical foundation for modern first - principles material physics. This not only resolves the contradictions in the classical approach but also provides a new perspective for future experimental and theoretical research.