New insight into light propagation and light-matter interactions with applications to experimental observations

Changbiao Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijleo.2019.163954

2019-10-01

Abstract:The paper provides a new understanding of light propagation and light-matter interactions by examining the physical implications of group velocity, electromagnetic (EM) power flow, Poynting theorem, energy conservation law, and Fermat's principle. A criterion is set up to identify the justification of the group velocity definition, and a modified definition is proposed to remove the flaws that the classical definition has. It is reasonably argued that energy conservation law and Fermat's principle are physical postulates independent of Maxwell equations. A ``superluminal power flow'' is constructed to show that Poynting theorem cannot uniquely define the EM power flow if the energy conservation law or Fermat's principle is not taken into account. As an application, associated basic concepts in textbooks and experimental observations reported in recent research works are also reviewed, including: why the traditional formulation of Fermat's principle has a limited application; how the Fermat's principle is formulated for a plane wave; why the Fermat's principle is consistent with Maxwell EM theory; what the significant difference is between Poynting theorem and energy conservation law; why Poynting vector as EM power flow may break energy conservation law and Fermat's principle in an anisotropic medium; why the physical explanations for ``spatially structured'' photons in Giovannini-coworkers experiments are not consistent with the principle of relativity; why the traditionally-argued invariance of information velocity contradicts Maxwell equations; and why the superluminal light pulse propagation claimed in Wang-Kuzmich-Dogariu experiments voilates Einstein causality.

General Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the basic theories of light propagation and the interaction between light and matter. Specifically:

1. **Defects in the classical group velocity definition**: The paper points out that the classical group velocity definition \(v_{\text{gr}} - c=\frac{\partial\omega}{\partial k_w}\) has two main defects:
- The group velocity may be greater than the phase velocity and violate Fermat's principle in non - dispersive, non - lossy, non - conductive anisotropic homogeneous media.
- The definition is inconsistent within the framework of relativity, especially in moving isotropic homogeneous media.

2. **Independence of the law of conservation of energy and Fermat's principle**: The paper emphasizes that the law of conservation of energy and Fermat's principle are physical assumptions independent of Maxwell's equations, and these principles have additional physical constraints on the direction of electromagnetic energy transfer.

3. **Modified group velocity definition**: To overcome the defects of the classical group velocity definition, the paper proposes a new group velocity definition \(v_{\text{gr}}=\hat{n}\frac{\partial\omega}{\partial|k_w|}\), where \(\hat{n}=\frac{k_w}{|k_w|}\) is the unit wave vector. The new definition defines the group velocity in the direction of the wave vector, thus eliminating the defects in the classical definition.

4. **Limitations of Poynting's theorem**: The paper points out that Poynting's theorem cannot uniquely define the electromagnetic power flow unless the law of conservation of energy or Fermat's principle is considered simultaneously. By constructing "superluminal power flow", the paper demonstrates this limitation of Poynting's theorem.

5. **Explanation of experimental observations**: The paper reviews the basic concepts in relevant textbooks and the experimental observations in recent research, especially explaining why the traditional formulation of Fermat's principle has limited application in some cases and why some experimental results (such as the experiments by Giovannini et al.) are inconsistent with the principles of relativity.

### Main contributions
- **Theoretical innovation**: A modified group velocity definition is proposed, which solves the physical inconsistency problems in the classical definition.
- **Clarification of physical principles**: The independence and importance of the law of conservation of energy and Fermat's principle in electromagnetism are clearly defined.
- **Explanation of experiments**: New explanations for some experimental phenomena are provided, especially for experiments involving superluminal pulse propagation.

### Conclusion
Through detailed theoretical analysis and experimental observations, the paper verifies the validity and necessity of the modified group velocity definition, providing a new theoretical basis for the research on light propagation and the interaction between light and matter.