Abstract:We consider small random perturbations of the standard high-symmetry tunneling potentials in the Bistritzer-MacDonald Hamiltonian describing twisted bilayer graphene. Using methods developed by Sjöstrand for studying the spectral asymptotics of non-selfadjoint pseudo-differential operators, we prove that for sufficiently small twisting angles the Hamiltonian will not exhibit a flat band with overwhelming probability, and hence the absence of the so-called \textit{magic angels}. Moreover, we prove a probabilistic Weyl law for the eigenvalues of the non-selfadjoint tunneling operator, subject to small random perturbations, of the Bistritzer-MacDonald Hamiltonian in the chiral limit.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether there are so - called "magic angles" in twisted bilayer graphene under the influence of small random perturbations on high - symmetry tunneling potentials. Specifically, the authors studied whether the phenomenon of flat bands would still occur in the twisted bilayer graphene system described by the Bistritzer - MacDonald Hamiltonian when small random perturbations were introduced. The existence of flat bands is related to strongly correlated electron phenomena, such as the superconducting phase. Therefore, understanding the stability of these flat bands under random perturbations is crucial for understanding the physical properties in twisted bilayer graphene.
### Main contributions of the paper
1. **Absence of small magic angles**:
- The authors proved that for a sufficiently small twist angle, the Hamiltonian does not exhibit flat bands in most cases, that is, the so - called "magic angles" hardly exist. This was achieved by using the method developed by Sjöstrand to study the spectral asymptotic behavior of non - self - adjoint pseudo - differential operators.
2. **Probabilistic Weyl law**:
- The authors also proved a probabilistic Weyl law for the eigenvalues of non - self - adjoint tunneling operators, which have the characteristics of the Bistritzer - MacDonald Hamiltonian under small random perturbations.
### Mathematical background
- **Bistritzer - MacDonald Hamiltonian**:
\[
H_{\text{BM}}(w, h)=\begin{pmatrix}
wC & D_h \\
D_h^* & wC
\end{pmatrix}
\]
where \( w \) is a parameter, \( h \) is proportional to the physical twist angle, and \( C \) and \( D_h \) represent matrix - valued terms respectively:
\[
D_h=\begin{pmatrix}
2hD_x & U(x) \\
U(-x) & 2hD_x
\end{pmatrix}, \quad C=\begin{pmatrix}
0 & V(x) \\
V(x) & 0
\end{pmatrix}
\]
- **Chiral limit**:
- In the chiral limit, the Hamiltonian simplifies to:
\[
H_{\text{chiral}}=\begin{pmatrix}
0 & D_h \\
D_h^* & 0
\end{pmatrix}
\]
- **Spectral theory**:
- The authors used spectral theory and random perturbation methods to prove that under small random perturbations, the probability that the lowest singular value of \( D_h \) is far from zero is very high, thus deducing the non - existence of flat bands or magic angles.
### Main results
- **Theorem 2.2**:
- For small random tunneling potential perturbations, the lowest singular value of the Hamiltonian \( D_h \) is not close to zero in most cases, so there are no flat bands or magic angles.
- The probability form of this result is:
\[
P\left( t_1(D_h^\delta - z)\geq\frac{\epsilon}{8(C\tau_0)^{N - 1}}\right)\geq1 - Ch^{-\kappa_5\epsilon_0(h)}\exp\left(-\frac{h^2}{C\epsilon_0(h)}\log\frac{1}{\epsilon}\right)
\]
- **Theorem 2.4**:
- Under small random perturbations, the chiral Hamiltonian \( H_{\text{chiral}}^\delta \) does not exhibit flat bands at zero energy, that is, for a sufficiently small \( h \), it is not a magic angle.
- The probability form of this result is:
\[
P\left( H_{\text{chiral}}^\delta \text{ has no flat bands at zero energy}\right)\geq1