Abstract:We prove that in the chiral limit of the Bistritzer-MacDonald Hamiltonian, there exist magic angles at which the Hamiltonian exhibits flat bands of multiplicity four instead of two. We analyze the structure of the Bloch functions associated with the four bands, the corresponding Chern number, and show that there exist infinitely many degenerate magic angles for a generic choice of tunnelling potentials.
Mathematical Physics,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Materials Science,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Analysis of PDEs
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in the twisted structure of bilayer graphene, there are so - called "magic angles". At these angles, the material exhibits strong electron correlation effects, such as superconductivity and the quantum Hall effect, without an external magnetic field. Specifically, the paper focuses on whether there are specific angles (i.e., magic angles) in the Bistritzer - MacDonald Hamiltonian model in the chiral limit, such that the Hamiltonian exhibits multiple - degenerate flat bands. The main contribution of the paper is to prove that at certain magic angles, the Hamiltonian can exhibit four - fold - degenerate flat bands, rather than just two - fold - degenerate flat bands. In addition, the paper also analyzes the structure of Bloch functions related to these four energy bands, calculates the corresponding Chern numbers, and shows that for a general tunneling potential, there are infinitely many degenerate magic angles.
### Main problems
1. **Existence of magic angles**: The paper attempts to prove whether there are magic angles in the Bistritzer - MacDonald Hamiltonian model in the chiral limit, such that the Hamiltonian exhibits four - fold - degenerate flat bands.
2. **Properties of flat bands**: Analyze the structure of Bloch functions related to these flat bands and calculate the corresponding Chern numbers.
3. **Universality of degenerate magic angles**: Prove that for a general tunneling potential, there are infinitely many degenerate magic angles.
### Solutions
1. **Mathematical proof**: Through strict mathematical proof, the paper shows that at certain magic angles, the Hamiltonian can exhibit four - fold - degenerate flat bands.
2. **Numerical simulation**: Through numerical experiments, the correctness of the theoretical prediction is verified.
3. **Spectral analysis**: Using spectral theory, the spectral characteristics of the Hamiltonian at different magic angles are analyzed.
### Main conclusions
1. **Four - fold - degenerate flat bands**: The paper proves that at certain magic angles, the Hamiltonian can exhibit four - fold - degenerate flat bands.
2. **Infinitely many degenerate magic angles**: For a general tunneling potential, there are infinitely many degenerate magic angles.
3. **Calculation of Chern numbers**: The Chern numbers of Bloch functions related to four - fold - degenerate flat bands are calculated, further verifying the topological properties of these flat bands.
### Formulas
The formulas involved in the paper include:
- Definition of the Hamiltonian:
\[
H(\alpha)=\begin{pmatrix}
0 & D(\alpha)^* \\
D(\alpha) & 0
\end{pmatrix}
\]
where \(D(\alpha)=\begin{pmatrix}
2D_{\bar{z}} & \alpha U_+(z) \\
\alpha U_-(z) & 2D_{\bar{z}}
\end{pmatrix}\)
- Definition of magic angles:
\[
m(\alpha)=\min\{j > 0:\max_k E_{j + 1}(\alpha,k)>0\}
\]
- Definition of Bloch functions:
\[
L_2^k=\{u\in L_2^{\text{loc}}(\mathbb{C};\mathbb{C}^4):L_a u = e^{i\langle k,a\rangle}u\}
\]
- Symmetry of the spectrum:
\[
\{E_j(\alpha,k)\}_{j\in\mathbb{Z}^*}, \quad E_j(\alpha,k)= - E_{-j}(\alpha,k)
\]
Through these formulas and theoretical analysis, the paper successfully solves the above problems and provides new insights into the magic - angle phenomenon in bilayer graphene.