Abstract:We demonstrate the generic existence of Dirac cones in the full Bistritzer--MacDonald Hamiltonian for twisted bilayer graphene. Its complementary set, when Dirac cones are absent, is the set of magic angles. We show the stability of magic angles obtained in the chiral limit by demonstrating that the perfectly flat bands transform into quadratic band crossings when perturbing away from the chiral limit. Moreover, using the invariance of Euler number, we show that at magic angles there are more band crossings beyond these quadratic band crossings. This is the first result showing the existence of magic angles for the full Bistritzer--MacDonald Hamiltonian and solves Open Problem No.2 proposed in the recent survey <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2310.20642" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20642">arXiv:2310.20642</a>.
Mathematical Physics,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Analysis of PDEs,Spectral Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to prove the existence of Dirac cones in the Bistritzer - MacDonald (BM) model of Twisted Bilayer Graphene (TBG), and to explore the stability of the so - called "magic angles". Specifically, the authors show the ubiquity of Dirac cones in the full BM Hamiltonian, and prove that when Dirac cones do not exist, that is, at the so - called magic angles, there are more band crossings. In addition, they also study the stability of these magic angles when deviating from the chiral limit.
### Main contributions of the paper
1. **Ubiquity of Dirac cones**: The authors prove that in the full BM Hamiltonian, Dirac cones are ubiquitous under most parameters. This is achieved by showing that when the parameters \((\alpha, \lambda)\) do not belong to certain specific analytic curves, the system will exhibit simple Dirac cones.
2. **Stability of magic angles**: The authors further prove that the magic angles obtained in the chiral limit remain stable when deviating from the chiral limit. This means that these magic angles are still valid even when more realistic physical conditions are considered.
3. **Additional properties of band crossings**: Using the invariance of the Euler number, the authors prove that at the magic angles, in addition to the quadratic band crossings, there are other band crossings. This finding is of great significance for understanding the energy band structure and electronic properties of the system.
### Mathematical models and methods
- **BM Hamiltonian**: The main mathematical model in the paper is the Bistritzer - MacDonald (BM) Hamiltonian, defined as:
\[
H(\alpha, \lambda)=\begin{pmatrix}
\lambda C & D(\alpha)^* \\
D(\alpha) & \lambda C
\end{pmatrix}
\]
where \(D(\alpha)\) and \(C\) are respectively represented as:
\[
D(\alpha)=\begin{pmatrix}
2D_{\bar{z}} & \alpha U(z) \\
\alpha U(-z) & 2D_{\bar{z}}
\end{pmatrix}, \quad C = \begin{pmatrix}
0 & V(z) \\
V(-z) & 0
\end{pmatrix}
\]
- **Symmetries**: The paper discusses in detail various symmetries of the BM Hamiltonian, including translational symmetry, rotational symmetry, as well as particle - hole symmetry and mirror symmetry. These symmetries play a crucial role in proving the existence of Dirac cones and the stability of magic angles.
- **Grushin problem**: To prove the existence of Dirac cones, the authors use the method of the Grushin problem. By constructing an appropriate Grushin problem, they can derive the asymptotic expansion of the energy eigenvalues, thereby proving the existence of Dirac cones.
### Conclusion
This paper solves the problem of the ubiquity of Dirac cones in the full BM Hamiltonian and proves the stability of magic angles. These results not only deepen the understanding of the electronic properties of twisted bilayer graphene but also provide an important theoretical basis for further research on strongly correlated physics.